Heavyconsumer
Junior Member
π¨οΈ 4,974
ππ» 5
February 2008
|
Cartrain π¬π§ Tate Gallery β’ Damien Hirst β’ Gilbert & George, by Heavyconsumer on Nov 7, 2008 16:19:06 GMT 1, Same old people  ;D
I would have just left my original "  ", were it not for your remark, which insinuates prejudice on the part of those previously posting. I'm pretty sure the last comment I made in a Cartrain related thread was a compliment on something he'd produced, but this work is just not worthy of showing to his own mother, let alone being sold by a gallery. It's an embarrasment that someone is selling this here imho!
This is a forum, so presumably what gets posted in here is open for sincere/genuine/honest/civilised comment/debate. Or at least that's my understanding - am I wrong? FWIW I agree with you 100% that unnecessary personal insults are totally out of order, but look at this work! Is there an idea, is there a concept, is there any aspect of it being remotely aesthetically pleasing, is there a clear message with which to connect/relate? Personally I have to say no on all counts. If these pieces were at a future auction, it is my belief that the postage stamps on the tubes would probably get more interest! That's how poor I think it is!
Same old people ;D I would have just left my original " ", were it not for your remark, which insinuates prejudice on the part of those previously posting. I'm pretty sure the last comment I made in a Cartrain related thread was a compliment on something he'd produced, but this work is just not worthy of showing to his own mother, let alone being sold by a gallery. It's an embarrasment that someone is selling this here imho! This is a forum, so presumably what gets posted in here is open for sincere/genuine/honest/civilised comment/debate. Or at least that's my understanding - am I wrong? FWIW I agree with you 100% that unnecessary personal insults are totally out of order, but look at this work! Is there an idea, is there a concept, is there any aspect of it being remotely aesthetically pleasing, is there a clear message with which to connect/relate? Personally I have to say no on all counts. If these pieces were at a future auction, it is my belief that the postage stamps on the tubes would probably get more interest! That's how poor I think it is! |
|
|
|
Cartrain π¬π§ Tate Gallery β’ Damien Hirst β’ Gilbert & George, by daz205 on Nov 7, 2008 16:34:39 GMT 1, 
reminds me of this is some abstract way that i`m not going to bother explaing
well done cartrain keep up the good work
reminds me of this is some abstract way that i`m not going to bother explaing well done cartrain keep up the good work |
|
m@san
New Member
π¨οΈ 354
ππ» 0
November 2006
|
Cartrain π¬π§ Tate Gallery β’ Damien Hirst β’ Gilbert & George, by m@san on Nov 7, 2008 16:44:14 GMT 1, no one goes on the cartrain forum thou
I wonder why !
no one goes on the cartrain forum thou I wonder why ! |
|
|
|
Cartrain π¬π§ Tate Gallery β’ Damien Hirst β’ Gilbert & George, by arcam on Nov 7, 2008 16:49:58 GMT 1, Same old people ;D
Same old Silky more like. At least folks here are honest with him.
Not so keen on the print  but the originals a quality ;D
Care to elaborate? What do you like about them?
Same old people ;D Same old Silky more like. At least folks here are honest with him. Not so keen on the print but the originals a quality ;D Care to elaborate? What do you like about them? |
|
|
|
Cartrain π¬π§ Tate Gallery β’ Damien Hirst β’ Gilbert & George, by graeme501 on Nov 7, 2008 17:21:58 GMT 1, every time these collages come out, everyone always asks what they are about, and cartain comes on and refuses to explain, but says he's told some people, but they never explain either
i would love an explaination for any of these works, if cartain thinks they are good enough to be sold through a gallery, then he should give a basic explaination of what they are about
if he doesnt, im 100% convinced he doesnt know either
every time these collages come out, everyone always asks what they are about, and cartain comes on and refuses to explain, but says he's told some people, but they never explain either
i would love an explaination for any of these works, if cartain thinks they are good enough to be sold through a gallery, then he should give a basic explaination of what they are about
if he doesnt, im 100% convinced he doesnt know either
|
|
|
|
Cartrain π¬π§ Tate Gallery β’ Damien Hirst β’ Gilbert & George, by daz205 on Nov 7, 2008 17:23:41 GMT 1,
Word from the artist..."The new artworks are a representation of sleepwalking into a dictatorship"
dont ya get it?
Word from the artist..."The new artworks are a representation of sleepwalking into a dictatorship"
dont ya get it? |
|
|
|
Heavyconsumer
Junior Member
π¨οΈ 4,974
ππ» 5
February 2008
|
Cartrain π¬π§ Tate Gallery β’ Damien Hirst β’ Gilbert & George, by Heavyconsumer on Nov 7, 2008 17:29:50 GMT 1,
Word from the artist..."The new artworks are a representation of sleepwalking into a dictatorship"
dont ya get it?
The odd thing is, I DO like some of what Cartrain TRYS to say with a lot of his work, I just don't think he's very successful at doing so. However, I certainly do not mean to bash the kid and I remain open-minded. I'm very happy to state I like his work, if and when I do. I'm not knocking the artist, just this god awful work he's produced (imo).
Word from the artist..."The new artworks are a representation of sleepwalking into a dictatorship"
dont ya get it? The odd thing is, I DO like some of what Cartrain TRYS to say with a lot of his work, I just don't think he's very successful at doing so. However, I certainly do not mean to bash the kid and I remain open-minded. I'm very happy to state I like his work, if and when I do. I'm not knocking the artist, just this god awful work he's produced (imo). |
|
Deleted
π¨οΈ 0
ππ»
January 1970
|
Cartrain π¬π§ Tate Gallery β’ Damien Hirst β’ Gilbert & George, by Deleted on Nov 7, 2008 17:32:48 GMT 1, Cartrain's 22, so lets discuss him as we would any other artist rather than as a kid trying his luck, he's been doing this a good number of years
Cartrain's 22, so lets discuss him as we would any other artist rather than as a kid trying his luck, he's been doing this a good number of years
|
|
HowAboutNo
New Member
π¨οΈ 756
ππ» 11
May 2006
|
Cartrain π¬π§ Tate Gallery β’ Damien Hirst β’ Gilbert & George, by HowAboutNo on Nov 7, 2008 17:36:37 GMT 1, Fuck me he's aged quickly, it's only last week he was banging the "I'm only 15 drum" rather loudly.
Fuck me he's aged quickly, it's only last week he was banging the "I'm only 15 drum" rather loudly.
|
|
|
|
Cartrain π¬π§ Tate Gallery β’ Damien Hirst β’ Gilbert & George, by graeme501 on Nov 7, 2008 17:38:07 GMT 1, i dont think he's 22...
i dont think he's 22...
|
|
Tyler Durden
New Member
π¨οΈ 742
ππ» 1
February 2007
|
Cartrain π¬π§ Tate Gallery β’ Damien Hirst β’ Gilbert & George, by Tyler Durden on Nov 7, 2008 17:43:29 GMT 1, He's 22.
He's 22.
|
|
|
|
Cartrain π¬π§ Tate Gallery β’ Damien Hirst β’ Gilbert & George, by graeme501 on Nov 7, 2008 17:46:11 GMT 1, fuck me, thats a year older than me, i'd like to think my stencils are better than cartains
fuck me, thats a year older than me, i'd like to think my stencils are better than cartains
|
|
stickitup
New Member
π¨οΈ 448
ππ» 3
June 2007
|
Cartrain π¬π§ Tate Gallery β’ Damien Hirst β’ Gilbert & George, by stickitup on Nov 7, 2008 18:21:31 GMT 1, anyone can be an artist....not everyone can be a good artist. what makes a good artist? i am unsure as it is subjective, however a main componant of it is how you communicate your idea - in this case via a visual means. I am unsure the visual protacol being used here is particularly successfully or appealing. However different strokes and all, its just there's a lot of people who don't find it communicates its point that well. In comparisom banksy is loved and got by nearly all as his one liners are perhaps too easily to understand, so he appeals to the mass demographic, rich, poor, intelligent, unintelligent, etc etc.
anyone can be an artist....not everyone can be a good artist. what makes a good artist? i am unsure as it is subjective, however a main componant of it is how you communicate your idea - in this case via a visual means. I am unsure the visual protacol being used here is particularly successfully or appealing. However different strokes and all, its just there's a lot of people who don't find it communicates its point that well. In comparisom banksy is loved and got by nearly all as his one liners are perhaps too easily to understand, so he appeals to the mass demographic, rich, poor, intelligent, unintelligent, etc etc.
|
|
|
|
Cartrain π¬π§ Tate Gallery β’ Damien Hirst β’ Gilbert & George, by graeme501 on Nov 7, 2008 18:24:14 GMT 1, i think that good art can be in the way the message is delivered, or in the aesthetic appeal, but the best art comes with a combination of both
i think that good art can be in the way the message is delivered, or in the aesthetic appeal, but the best art comes with a combination of both
|
|
|
|
|
|
Cartrain π¬π§ Tate Gallery β’ Damien Hirst β’ Gilbert & George, by Daniel Silk on Nov 8, 2008 2:48:16 GMT 1, I think he meant, "Shouldn't this ONLY be on the cartrain forum". Or perhaps in the artists section of this forum.
We also have threads on the first page of this section about - Faile, Herakut, Shepard Fairey, Borf, Hush, Dolk, Guy Denning, Paul Insect, Nick Walker, Prefab, Inkie, Grafter, Coptright & Eine. What would you like done about those?
I think he meant, "Shouldn't this ONLY be on the cartrain forum". Or perhaps in the artists section of this forum. We also have threads on the first page of this section about - Faile, Herakut, Shepard Fairey, Borf, Hush, Dolk, Guy Denning, Paul Insect, Nick Walker, Prefab, Inkie, Grafter, Coptright & Eine. What would you like done about those? |
|
seidbereit
Junior Member
π¨οΈ 1,743
ππ» 5
November 2007
|
Cartrain π¬π§ Tate Gallery β’ Damien Hirst β’ Gilbert & George, by seidbereit on Nov 8, 2008 11:50:41 GMT 1,
Has Cartrain grown two additional legs and a tail?
I can think of no other rational explanation for his having aged 7 years in a period of 12 months.
Has Cartrain grown two additional legs and a tail? I can think of no other rational explanation for his having aged 7 years in a period of 12 months. |
|
jusdeep
Junior Member
π¨οΈ 2,797
ππ» 464
October 2007
|
Cartrain π¬π§ Tate Gallery β’ Damien Hirst β’ Gilbert & George, by jusdeep on Nov 8, 2008 12:18:22 GMT 1, He's adapting, it's all those books he's been reading
He's adapting, it's all those books he's been reading |
|
mace
Junior Member
π¨οΈ 1,491
ππ» 288
August 2008
|
Cartrain π¬π§ Tate Gallery β’ Damien Hirst β’ Gilbert & George, by mace on Nov 8, 2008 21:59:39 GMT 1, Logo is crap, work is crap - as usual...
Logo is crap, work is crap - as usual...
|
|
|
|
Cartrain π¬π§ Tate Gallery β’ Damien Hirst β’ Gilbert & George, by wiz on Nov 8, 2008 22:04:50 GMT 1, Say what you like about Cartrains works but they certainly get people talking.
Say what you like about Cartrains works but they certainly get people talking.
|
|
curiousgeorge
Junior Member
π¨οΈ 5,833
ππ» 1,091
March 2007
|
Cartrain π¬π§ Tate Gallery β’ Damien Hirst β’ Gilbert & George, by curiousgeorge on Nov 8, 2008 22:29:59 GMT 1, Fcuk me David Duchovny is a member here??
Fcuk me David Duchovny is a member here??
|
|
Wearology
Junior Member
Staff at FatFreeArt
π¨οΈ 3,596
ππ» 4,512
April 2008
|
Cartrain π¬π§ Tate Gallery β’ Damien Hirst β’ Gilbert & George, by Wearology on Nov 8, 2008 22:32:07 GMT 1, yikes - I meant to send those pics to Wizbong PM - anyone I ever tried to negotiate with please disregard these photos - not good I need computer lessons
yikes - I meant to send those pics to Wizbong PM - anyone I ever tried to negotiate with please disregard these photos - not good I need computer lessons
|
|
|
|
Cartrain π¬π§ Tate Gallery β’ Damien Hirst β’ Gilbert & George, by wiz on Nov 8, 2008 22:32:33 GMT 1, Haha those are excellent! you know i do admire your art collection so much. Thank you!.
Haha those are excellent! you know i do admire your art collection so much. Thank you!.
|
|
|
|
Richard
Junior Member
π¨οΈ 1,367
ππ» 199
September 2007
|
Cartrain π¬π§ Tate Gallery β’ Damien Hirst β’ Gilbert & George, by Richard on Nov 8, 2008 22:42:35 GMT 1, ACE. ;D
ACE. ;D
|
|
|
|
Cartrain π¬π§ Tate Gallery β’ Damien Hirst β’ Gilbert & George, by Daniel Silk on Nov 8, 2008 22:54:07 GMT 1, ahhhhhh! he's just stood in front of those in a gallery ;D The only way you can prove they are yours is buy showing us a photos with you totally naked in front of them ;D ;D ;D ;D
With certain areas blurred please  ;D
ahhhhhh! he's just stood in front of those in a gallery ;D The only way you can prove they are yours is buy showing us a photos with you totally naked in front of them ;D ;D ;D ;D With certain areas blurred please ;D |
|
Richard
Junior Member
π¨οΈ 1,367
ππ» 199
September 2007
|
Cartrain π¬π§ Tate Gallery β’ Damien Hirst β’ Gilbert & George, by Richard on Nov 8, 2008 23:04:00 GMT 1, ahhhhhh! he's just stood in front of those in a gallery ;D The only way you can prove they are yours is buy showing us a photos with you totally naked in front of them ;D ;D ;D ;D With certain areas blurred please ;D
Similar to the way we all know Greames Gold Flag is real! LOL!
ahhhhhh! he's just stood in front of those in a gallery ;D The only way you can prove they are yours is buy showing us a photos with you totally naked in front of them ;D ;D ;D ;D With certain areas blurred please ;D Similar to the way we all know Greames Gold Flag is real! LOL! |
|
|
|
Cartrain π¬π§ Tate Gallery β’ Damien Hirst β’ Gilbert & George, by cashman on Nov 8, 2008 23:08:33 GMT 1, Hey Wiz I wanted to send you a picture of my two new Hirsts - be well Dave enjoy the photos !  
ive got art envy
Hey Wiz I wanted to send you a picture of my two new Hirsts - be well Dave enjoy the photos ! ive got art envy |
|
|
|
Cartrain π¬π§ Tate Gallery β’ Damien Hirst β’ Gilbert & George, by graeme501 on Nov 8, 2008 23:11:19 GMT 1, ahhhhhh! he's just stood in front of those in a gallery ;D The only way you can prove they are yours is buy showing us a photos with you totally naked in front of them ;D ;D ;D ;D With certain areas blurred please ;D Similar to the way we all know Greames Gold Flag is real! LOL!
never mind pest control, i have the best prov. around
ahhhhhh! he's just stood in front of those in a gallery ;D The only way you can prove they are yours is buy showing us a photos with you totally naked in front of them ;D ;D ;D ;D With certain areas blurred please ;D Similar to the way we all know Greames Gold Flag is real! LOL! never mind pest control, i have the best prov. around |
|
|
|
Cartrain π¬π§ Tate Gallery β’ Damien Hirst β’ Gilbert & George, by wiz on Nov 8, 2008 23:17:40 GMT 1, ahhhhhh! he's just stood in front of those in a gallery ;D The only way you can prove they are yours is buy showing us a photos with you totally naked in front of them ;D ;D ;D ;D With certain areas blurred please ;D
Its not a gallery Silky, sorry 
ahhhhhh! he's just stood in front of those in a gallery ;D The only way you can prove they are yours is buy showing us a photos with you totally naked in front of them ;D ;D ;D ;D With certain areas blurred please ;D Its not a gallery Silky, sorry |
|
|
|
Cartrain π¬π§ Tate Gallery β’ Damien Hirst β’ Gilbert & George, by Guest on Nov 8, 2008 23:19:44 GMT 1, Hey Wiz I wanted to send you a picture of my two new Hirsts - be well Dave enjoy the photos ! fuck are these by Cartrain
Hey Wiz I wanted to send you a picture of my two new Hirsts - be well Dave enjoy the photos ! fuck are these by Cartrain |
|
Wearology
Junior Member
Staff at FatFreeArt
π¨οΈ 3,596
ππ» 4,512
April 2008
|
Cartrain π¬π§ Tate Gallery β’ Damien Hirst β’ Gilbert & George, by Wearology on Nov 8, 2008 23:25:12 GMT 1, my goal was to send the photo to Wiz not the whole forum - I am not offended that some of you guys think I am in a gallery asked someone for a pen and a large legal pad wrote on it I love Wizbong and than had another photo taken with a new sign I love Mammal - I am traveling until Monday but when I return in order to satisfy you detectives in the crowd I will take a picture of me taking the Hirst off the wall - I guess if it was in a gallery secuirity would frown upon that kind of stuff - the Valium piece is massive so there might be 2 people in the photo -
my goal was to send the photo to Wiz not the whole forum - I am not offended that some of you guys think I am in a gallery asked someone for a pen and a large legal pad wrote on it I love Wizbong and than had another photo taken with a new sign I love Mammal - I am traveling until Monday but when I return in order to satisfy you detectives in the crowd I will take a picture of me taking the Hirst off the wall - I guess if it was in a gallery secuirity would frown upon that kind of stuff - the Valium piece is massive so there might be 2 people in the photo -
|
|
;D
", were it not for your remark, which insinuates prejudice on the part of those previously posting. I'm pretty sure the last comment I made in a Cartrain related thread was a compliment on something he'd produced, but this work is just not worthy of showing to his own mother, let alone being sold by a gallery. It's an embarrasment that someone is selling this here imho!
but the originals a quality ;D
;D 
