dreadnatty
Junior Member
Posts โข 5,431
Likes โข 6,992
February 2013
|
Mr.Brainwash sues Life is Beautiful Festival, by dreadnatty on Nov 10, 2014 1:09:04 GMT 1, Oh,the irony.
www.tmz.com/2014/11/09/mr-brainwash-vegas-life-is-beautiful-heart-lawsuit/
The street artist known as Mr. Brainwash lost more than just his shirt in Vegas ... he lost a big chunk of his identity -- and now he's suing to get it back.
Mr. Brainwash, who's real name is Thierry Guetta, says he's been incorporating the phrase ... "Life is Beautiful" into his street art for years -- and even has trademarks -- but he says a Vegas company has jacked it.
According to the lawsuit -- obtained by TMZ -- a Vegas street fair now goes by "Life is Beautiful" ... and uses an image of a heart made of splashed paint ... which is also one of Mr. Brainwash's trademarks.
Mr. B says the street festival is creating confusion in the street art marketplace. He wants a judge to rip the title and image from the festival.
C'est la belle vie.
Read more: www.tmz.com/2014/11/09/mr-brainwash-vegas-life-is-beautiful-heart-lawsuit/#ixzz3IcTIQVhT
Oh,the irony. www.tmz.com/2014/11/09/mr-brainwash-vegas-life-is-beautiful-heart-lawsuit/The street artist known as Mr. Brainwash lost more than just his shirt in Vegas ... he lost a big chunk of his identity -- and now he's suing to get it back. Mr. Brainwash, who's real name is Thierry Guetta, says he's been incorporating the phrase ... "Life is Beautiful" into his street art for years -- and even has trademarks -- but he says a Vegas company has jacked it. According to the lawsuit -- obtained by TMZ -- a Vegas street fair now goes by "Life is Beautiful" ... and uses an image of a heart made of splashed paint ... which is also one of Mr. Brainwash's trademarks. Mr. B says the street festival is creating confusion in the street art marketplace. He wants a judge to rip the title and image from the festival. C'est la belle vie. Read more: www.tmz.com/2014/11/09/mr-brainwash-vegas-life-is-beautiful-heart-lawsuit/#ixzz3IcTIQVhT
|
|
commissioner
New Member
Posts โข 931
Likes โข 1,208
May 2014
|
Mr.Brainwash sues Life is Beautiful Festival, by commissioner on Nov 10, 2014 1:25:18 GMT 1,
|
|
Segment
New Member
Posts โข 456
Likes โข 386
September 2014
|
Mr.Brainwash sues Life is Beautiful Festival, by Segment on Nov 10, 2014 1:28:45 GMT 1, Joke's or should i say joker!
Joke's or should i say joker!
|
|
yoyosh
Junior Member
Posts โข 1,683
Likes โข 1,631
March 2012
|
Mr.Brainwash sues Life is Beautiful Festival, by yoyosh on Nov 10, 2014 1:35:43 GMT 1, I don't blame him one bit. Say what you want but when I heard of the festival and saw their advertising I was sure this was either HIS EVENT or that he was at least part of it as a figurehead etc.
I don't blame him one bit. Say what you want but when I heard of the festival and saw their advertising I was sure this was either HIS EVENT or that he was at least part of it as a figurehead etc.
|
|
Dr Plip
Junior Member
Posts โข 7,043
Likes โข 8,981
August 2011
|
Mr.Brainwash sues Life is Beautiful Festival, by Dr Plip on Nov 10, 2014 2:07:32 GMT 1, All this recent talk of copyright and trademarks is making me so horny.
All this recent talk of copyright and trademarks is making me so horny.
|
|
WOOF
Junior Member
Posts โข 4,458
Likes โข 4,753
March 2014
|
Mr.Brainwash sues Life is Beautiful Festival, by WOOF on Nov 10, 2014 2:12:34 GMT 1, Vincenzo Cerami and Roberto Benigni should sue MBW for stealing their movie title.
Vincenzo Cerami and Roberto Benigni should sue MBW for stealing their movie title.
|
|
|
randomname
Junior Member
Posts โข 1,962
Likes โข 1,810
June 2013
|
Mr.Brainwash sues Life is Beautiful Festival, by randomname on Nov 10, 2014 2:22:56 GMT 1, I really doubt any copyright or trademark claim will hold up in court. The language is far too common. It would be like trying to claim "The sky is blue."
I really doubt any copyright or trademark claim will hold up in court. The language is far too common. It would be like trying to claim "The sky is blue."
|
|
sgolby
Junior Member
Posts โข 1,890
Likes โข 2,892
November 2012
|
Mr.Brainwash sues Life is Beautiful Festival, by sgolby on Nov 10, 2014 2:46:34 GMT 1, This is laughable...
This is laughable...
|
|
yoyosh
Junior Member
Posts โข 1,683
Likes โข 1,631
March 2012
|
Mr.Brainwash sues Life is Beautiful Festival, by yoyosh on Nov 10, 2014 3:25:48 GMT 1, Look at their logo guys. Say what you will about his stuff but... www.wirtzbev.com/assets/images/news/LIB.jpg
|
|
Deleted
Posts โข 0
Likes โข
January 1970
|
Mr.Brainwash sues Life is Beautiful Festival, by Deleted on Nov 10, 2014 3:41:46 GMT 1, I really doubt any copyright or trademark claim will hold up in court. The language is far too common. It would be like trying to claim "The sky is blue." There is currently a lawsuit over trademarking the word "how".
I really doubt any copyright or trademark claim will hold up in court. The language is far too common. It would be like trying to claim "The sky is blue." There is currently a lawsuit over trademarking the word "how".
|
|
lucky7
New Member
Posts โข 423
Likes โข 178
June 2014
|
Mr.Brainwash sues Life is Beautiful Festival, by lucky7 on Nov 10, 2014 7:44:40 GMT 1, Vincenzo Cerami and Roberto Benigni should sue MBW for stealing their movie title. Schopenhauer should sue him for false advertisement or libel.
Vincenzo Cerami and Roberto Benigni should sue MBW for stealing their movie title. Schopenhauer should sue him for false advertisement or libel.
|
|
johnnyh
Junior Member
Posts โข 4,492
Likes โข 2,102
March 2011
|
Mr.Brainwash sues Life is Beautiful Festival, by johnnyh on Nov 10, 2014 9:41:38 GMT 1, He he all litigation on here these days. Reckon he will lose that one....I think but you never know...mad mad mad. His career is based on using images of others then starts litigation ....brilliant
He he all litigation on here these days. Reckon he will lose that one....I think but you never know...mad mad mad. His career is based on using images of others then starts litigation ....brilliant
|
|
|
Mr.Brainwash sues Life is Beautiful Festival, by Jeezuz Jones Snr on Nov 10, 2014 10:02:14 GMT 1, Seriously what a tool!! As if he hasn't made enough money already..
Seriously what a tool!! As if he hasn't made enough money already..
|
|
urbanflik
New Member
Posts โข 483
Likes โข 372
February 2010
|
Mr.Brainwash sues Life is Beautiful Festival, by urbanflik on Nov 10, 2014 10:30:41 GMT 1, Even though Brainwash is considered a joke for most when it comes to his art, i agree with him.
Its not pretty that hes going to shoot such a great cultural event down, but they must be a little silly to have plagiarised someones work who is in the same field/target market as their users, i.e urban/street art.
Hopefully they can come to an amicable resolution, otherwise it will get messy and Life Is Beautiful may find that they are handing a percentage of profits from historical events too.
Even though Brainwash is considered a joke for most when it comes to his art, i agree with him.
Its not pretty that hes going to shoot such a great cultural event down, but they must be a little silly to have plagiarised someones work who is in the same field/target market as their users, i.e urban/street art.
Hopefully they can come to an amicable resolution, otherwise it will get messy and Life Is Beautiful may find that they are handing a percentage of profits from historical events too.
|
|
|
Invaded 420
Junior Member
Posts โข 2,741
Likes โข 1,928
August 2013
|
Mr.Brainwash sues Life is Beautiful Festival, by Invaded 420 on Nov 10, 2014 10:55:24 GMT 1, I say good on brainwash. Wouldn't buy his stuff myself but some of the stuff his elves churn out I like. Great guy aswell.
I say good on brainwash. Wouldn't buy his stuff myself but some of the stuff his elves churn out I like. Great guy aswell.
|
|
Emile
New Member
Posts โข 825
Likes โข 477
October 2013
|
Mr.Brainwash sues Life is Beautiful Festival, by Emile on Nov 10, 2014 10:58:05 GMT 1, First thing I thought of when I read the name was MBW. Didn't even realize they were using the heart. Fair play by him imo
First thing I thought of when I read the name was MBW. Didn't even realize they were using the heart. Fair play by him imo
|
|
adewilliams
Junior Member
Posts โข 1,190
Likes โข 321
May 2009
|
Mr.Brainwash sues Life is Beautiful Festival, by adewilliams on Nov 10, 2014 11:00:04 GMT 1, beautiful life is
beautiful life is
|
|
Deleted
Posts โข 0
Likes โข
January 1970
|
Mr.Brainwash sues Life is Beautiful Festival, by Deleted on Nov 10, 2014 14:02:04 GMT 1, I've got to agree with MBW here, though it's not that they used the phrase "Life is Beautiful". it's that they used the phrase, and the drippy heart to try to dupe people into thinking he was associated with the event. It's about the context, not necessarily the content
I've got to agree with MBW here, though it's not that they used the phrase "Life is Beautiful". it's that they used the phrase, and the drippy heart to try to dupe people into thinking he was associated with the event. It's about the context, not necessarily the content
|
|
raindogs
New Member
Posts โข 462
Likes โข 482
June 2011
|
|
|
Deleted
Posts โข 0
Likes โข
January 1970
|
Mr.Brainwash sues Life is Beautiful Festival, by Deleted on Nov 10, 2014 14:39:16 GMT 1, scrabbling for cash is an unseemly business
another nail in the coffin of street art- though it has been dead for some time
if you are in it for the money , get out now
scrabbling for cash is an unseemly business
another nail in the coffin of street art- though it has been dead for some time
if you are in it for the money , get out now
|
|
sgolby
Junior Member
Posts โข 1,890
Likes โข 2,892
November 2012
|
Mr.Brainwash sues Life is Beautiful Festival, by sgolby on Nov 10, 2014 15:18:59 GMT 1, I've got to agree with MBW here, though it's not that they used the phrase "Life is Beautiful". it's that they used the phrase, and the drippy heart to try to dupe people into thinking he was associated with the event. It's about the context, not necessarily the content I think iis brilliant that they did this. I mean it is preposterous that Thierry would consider suing them after all the garbage he has put out, featurin 99% lifted images... And 99% is generous. In my opinion lifting these words and the image serves two purposes. First it delegitimizes his work by essentially equatig it to a liftable stock image. At the same time it appropriates his work and says here is some real street art and we are going to flip a pretender's "slogan" into somethin meaingful for street art. To me Thierry Gueta is to art is the what vanilla ice is to rap.
I've got to agree with MBW here, though it's not that they used the phrase "Life is Beautiful". it's that they used the phrase, and the drippy heart to try to dupe people into thinking he was associated with the event. It's about the context, not necessarily the content I think iis brilliant that they did this. I mean it is preposterous that Thierry would consider suing them after all the garbage he has put out, featurin 99% lifted images... And 99% is generous. In my opinion lifting these words and the image serves two purposes. First it delegitimizes his work by essentially equatig it to a liftable stock image. At the same time it appropriates his work and says here is some real street art and we are going to flip a pretender's "slogan" into somethin meaingful for street art. To me Thierry Gueta is to art is the what vanilla ice is to rap.
|
|
sipps
New Member
Posts โข 253
Likes โข 74
November 2013
|
Mr.Brainwash sues Life is Beautiful Festival, by sipps on Nov 10, 2014 15:25:04 GMT 1, what a goon, just change the heart logo and let's move on - LIB does look like a decent music festival though...
what a goon, just change the heart logo and let's move on - LIB does look like a decent music festival though...
|
|
|
Deleted
Posts โข 0
Likes โข
January 1970
|
Mr.Brainwash sues Life is Beautiful Festival, by Deleted on Nov 10, 2014 15:42:42 GMT 1, Was the cocaine comment on the TMZ article aimed at Brainwash?
I doubt he was the first person to have written life is beautiful on a wall with a spray can.
The Life is beautiful festival lifeisbeautiful.com/category/news/ is a festival and not a shit self promoting so called art exhibition as done by Brainwash.
Brainwash wasn't the first person to throw or blob paint on images and the heart logo for the festival has some splashes on it.
Pollock and others did it and so did Dali.
Does Brainwash think that he is the only person allowed to splash heart shaped art?
Maybe he's just an egocentric thicko who believes his own hype and bullshit, but one things for certain his art is shit.
Thanks Banksy.
Was the cocaine comment on the TMZ article aimed at Brainwash? I doubt he was the first person to have written life is beautiful on a wall with a spray can. The Life is beautiful festival lifeisbeautiful.com/category/news/ is a festival and not a shit self promoting so called art exhibition as done by Brainwash. Brainwash wasn't the first person to throw or blob paint on images and the heart logo for the festival has some splashes on it. Pollock and others did it and so did Dali. Does Brainwash think that he is the only person allowed to splash heart shaped art? Maybe he's just an egocentric thicko who believes his own hype and bullshit, but one things for certain his art is shit. Thanks Banksy.
|
|
Deleted
Posts โข 0
Likes โข
January 1970
|
|
|
Deleted
Posts โข 0
Likes โข
January 1970
|
Mr.Brainwash sues Life is Beautiful Festival, by Deleted on Nov 10, 2014 15:50:47 GMT 1, All this recent talk of copyright and trademarks is making me so horny. I'm sorry, the phrase "Me so horny" is Trademarked by the band 2 Live Crew, sampling from the 1987 movie "Full Metal Jacket", which features a main character nicknamed "Gomer Pyle", a name taken from "The Andy Grifith Show".
All this recent talk of copyright and trademarks is making me so horny. I'm sorry, the phrase "Me so horny" is Trademarked by the band 2 Live Crew, sampling from the 1987 movie "Full Metal Jacket", which features a main character nicknamed "Gomer Pyle", a name taken from "The Andy Grifith Show".
|
|
Deleted
Posts โข 0
Likes โข
January 1970
|
|
|
chichi carter
Junior Member
Posts โข 1,265
Likes โข 1,056
February 2011
|
Mr.Brainwash sues Life is Beautiful Festival, by chichi carter on Nov 10, 2014 16:21:31 GMT 1, This forum should sue TMZ for referring to Mr. Brainwash as 'Mr. B'. There's only one 'Mr. B' TMZ staff, and that's Banksy! Clearly they've never been on here otherwise they would be well aware of that.
This forum should sue TMZ for referring to Mr. Brainwash as 'Mr. B'. There's only one 'Mr. B' TMZ staff, and that's Banksy! Clearly they've never been on here otherwise they would be well aware of that.
|
|
Deleted
Posts โข 0
Likes โข
January 1970
|
Mr.Brainwash sues Life is Beautiful Festival, by Deleted on Nov 10, 2014 16:27:14 GMT 1,
|
|
raindogs
New Member
Posts โข 462
Likes โข 482
June 2011
|
Mr.Brainwash sues Life is Beautiful Festival, by raindogs on Nov 10, 2014 16:36:22 GMT 1, (...) Thierry Guetta aka Mr. Brainwash (โMr. Guettaโ) is a prominent artist whose work has received significant press in numerous publications around the world. As a result of his innovative artwork and efforts, Mr. Guetta has received many awards and has gained recognition as an industry leader in developing and exhibiting creative artwork that has gained widespread popularity and demand among consumers. Mr. Guetta has an ownership interest in Plaintiff (A________, LLC), and Plaintiff is the registered owner of various trademarks and copyrights created by Mr. Guetta. (...) Its A W________, Inc. (โW_______โ) is a California corporation in which Mr. Guetta has an ownership interest. In June 2008, W________ held an art show in Los Angeles, California that was called and known among the public as โLIFE IS BEAUTIFULโ , in which artwork that Mr. Guetta had created was prominently showcased . The event was highly advertised and received a great amount of unsolicited media attention throughout the United States. Plaintiff is also the owner of certain trademarks and copyrights for various images of splashed paint hear t de signs (the โHeart Designsโ) . As early as 2009, Plaintiff and/or Mr. Guetta began using and continue to use the Heart Designs in commerce in connection with his art work and art shows in addition to various products, including but not limited to clothing s uch as T - shirts, kitchenware such as plates, and cell phone covers. (...) Plaintiff owns copyrighted images of the Heart Designs (...) To the extent that any of Plaintiffโs alleged right, title, or interest in any of the Heart Designs was previously owned by Mr. Guetta, any and all right, title and interest therein, including all rights to sue and recover for and the right to profits or damages in connection therewith, has been assigned to Plaintiff. (etc. etc. etc.)
(...) Thierry Guetta aka Mr. Brainwash (โMr. Guettaโ) is a prominent artist whose work has received significant press in numerous publications around the world. As a result of his innovative artwork and efforts, Mr. Guetta has received many awards and has gained recognition as an industry leader in developing and exhibiting creative artwork that has gained widespread popularity and demand among consumers. Mr. Guetta has an ownership interest in Plaintiff (A________, LLC), and Plaintiff is the registered owner of various trademarks and copyrights created by Mr. Guetta. (...) Its A W________, Inc. (โW_______โ) is a California corporation in which Mr. Guetta has an ownership interest. In June 2008, W________ held an art show in Los Angeles, California that was called and known among the public as โLIFE IS BEAUTIFULโ , in which artwork that Mr. Guetta had created was prominently showcased . The event was highly advertised and received a great amount of unsolicited media attention throughout the United States. Plaintiff is also the owner of certain trademarks and copyrights for various images of splashed paint hear t de signs (the โHeart Designsโ) . As early as 2009, Plaintiff and/or Mr. Guetta began using and continue to use the Heart Designs in commerce in connection with his art work and art shows in addition to various products, including but not limited to clothing s uch as T - shirts, kitchenware such as plates, and cell phone covers. (...) Plaintiff owns copyrighted images of the Heart Designs (...) To the extent that any of Plaintiffโs alleged right, title, or interest in any of the Heart Designs was previously owned by Mr. Guetta, any and all right, title and interest therein, including all rights to sue and recover for and the right to profits or damages in connection therewith, has been assigned to Plaintiff. (etc. etc. etc.)
|
|
randomname
Junior Member
Posts โข 1,962
Likes โข 1,810
June 2013
|
Mr.Brainwash sues Life is Beautiful Festival, by randomname on Nov 10, 2014 17:18:33 GMT 1, I really doubt any copyright or trademark claim will hold up in court. The language is far too common. It would be like trying to claim "The sky is blue." There is currently a lawsuit over trademarking the word "how". You can literally sue anyone for anything. That doesn't mean it'll hold up in court. Most likely, he's probably trying to pressure them into licensing the phrase for less than it would cost to defend in court. But trademark claims on common phrases have almost no chance of winning a jury trial.
I really doubt any copyright or trademark claim will hold up in court. The language is far too common. It would be like trying to claim "The sky is blue." There is currently a lawsuit over trademarking the word "how". You can literally sue anyone for anything. That doesn't mean it'll hold up in court. Most likely, he's probably trying to pressure them into licensing the phrase for less than it would cost to defend in court. But trademark claims on common phrases have almost no chance of winning a jury trial.
|
|