Balboa
New Member
๐จ๏ธ 976
๐๐ป 1,409
November 2007
|
Vladimir Putin's invasion of Ukraine ๐บ๐ฆ, by Balboa on Feb 26, 2022 9:12:21 GMT 1, I don't know about anybody else, but I'm impressed with how we've all gone from being experts in epidemiology to knowing everything about geopolitics.
I don't know about anybody else, but I'm impressed with how we've all gone from being experts in epidemiology to knowing everything about geopolitics.
|
|
Bill Hicks
New Member
๐จ๏ธ 939
๐๐ป 1,143
May 2008
|
|
|
ncewnimw
New Member
๐จ๏ธ 568
๐๐ป 419
November 2011
|
Vladimir Putin's invasion of Ukraine ๐บ๐ฆ, by ncewnimw on Feb 26, 2022 10:38:14 GMT 1, The Ukranians are free, the Russians are not. Soon they will both be unfree.
All in the hands of a man with a twisted ego. So sad ๐. #putler
The Ukranians are free, the Russians are not. Soon they will both be unfree. All in the hands of a man with a twisted ego. So sad ๐. #putler
|
|
seqret
Junior Member
๐จ๏ธ 2,133
๐๐ป 1,135
October 2011
|
Vladimir Putin's invasion of Ukraine ๐บ๐ฆ, by seqret on Feb 26, 2022 11:22:09 GMT 1, I was born in Moscow, USSR, had USSR passport, now I live in Moscow, Russia. Same city, different country. My father was born in Kyiv, USSR. Had passport of USSR country. Hope everyone involved will be safe Sorry I didn't get your last question. 6am here A lot of double speak and obfuscation. Everyone involved (does this also include for you the Russian aggressors?) wonโt be safe. Your USSR is gone and your Russia is attacking and killing Ukrainians. . Donโt believe everything you read #putinproud You didn't understand properly what I write or maybe it's my English. Whatever. Learn a bit of history. Ok. Your choice. I'm not an aggressor. Most of the Russian people don't support any kind of war and conflict including this one. We had enough in the past. Thats it.
And I don't watch TV fyi at all or read papers. Was just on the phone in the morning with my Ukranian relatives and friends from Kyiv. I just state what I know from real people. You still won't believe me hence I don't think this conversation will be constructive.
I know I'll open a can of worms but just a thought (I'm not defending my governments decisions).. how I need to call US and NATO for their past? Maybe for decisions in Belgrade bypassing UN or a few other countries? But I'm not calling people aggressors, their governments are wrong of course including ours. Thats not the way to solve things. I know a lot of good people from US and Europe so it's sad when someone is saying russians are bad, evil etc. We're not.
I was born in Moscow, USSR, had USSR passport, now I live in Moscow, Russia. Same city, different country. My father was born in Kyiv, USSR. Had passport of USSR country. Hope everyone involved will be safe Sorry I didn't get your last question. 6am here A lot of double speak and obfuscation. Everyone involved (does this also include for you the Russian aggressors?) wonโt be safe. Your USSR is gone and your Russia is attacking and killing Ukrainians. . Donโt believe everything you read #putinproud You didn't understand properly what I write or maybe it's my English. Whatever. Learn a bit of history. Ok. Your choice. I'm not an aggressor. Most of the Russian people don't support any kind of war and conflict including this one. We had enough in the past. Thats it. And I don't watch TV fyi at all or read papers. Was just on the phone in the morning with my Ukranian relatives and friends from Kyiv. I just state what I know from real people. You still won't believe me hence I don't think this conversation will be constructive. I know I'll open a can of worms but just a thought (I'm not defending my governments decisions).. how I need to call US and NATO for their past? Maybe for decisions in Belgrade bypassing UN or a few other countries? But I'm not calling people aggressors, their governments are wrong of course including ours. Thats not the way to solve things. I know a lot of good people from US and Europe so it's sad when someone is saying russians are bad, evil etc. We're not.
|
|
seqret
Junior Member
๐จ๏ธ 2,133
๐๐ป 1,135
October 2011
|
Vladimir Putin's invasion of Ukraine ๐บ๐ฆ, by seqret on Feb 26, 2022 11:25:27 GMT 1, I don't know about anybody else, but I'm impressed with how we've all gone from being experts in epidemiology to knowing everything about geopolitics. Sad but true
I don't know about anybody else, but I'm impressed with how we've all gone from being experts in epidemiology to knowing everything about geopolitics. Sad but true
|
|
sandinista
New Member
๐จ๏ธ 571
๐๐ป 474
April 2020
|
Vladimir Putin's invasion of Ukraine ๐บ๐ฆ, by sandinista on Feb 26, 2022 12:05:47 GMT 1, I know this is an art forum but i cant think about art at the moment apart from wanting artists to target putin in their art or pro Ukraine. This affects us art collectors as well. Is art a safe haven like gold? Are you thinking i should spend money elsewhere? Sell my art and move to new zealand? Your oension is being whacked if in the stock market, you will be paying ยฃ3k for energy, ยฃ2 a litre fuel, ยฃ5 a loaf of bread. Does art matter at the moment? At first when reading your message I thought your concern was for the people of Ukraine, but it quickly became clear your concern was for your bank balance.
Think what you like. Someone posted this is an art forum. This will impact markets including art. I thought id address that it also fits on art forum. Ukraine comes first concern and then what happens after that. Art is the least of most peoples worries apart from the well off moving out of stocks amd into safe havens.
I know this is an art forum but i cant think about art at the moment apart from wanting artists to target putin in their art or pro Ukraine. This affects us art collectors as well. Is art a safe haven like gold? Are you thinking i should spend money elsewhere? Sell my art and move to new zealand? Your oension is being whacked if in the stock market, you will be paying ยฃ3k for energy, ยฃ2 a litre fuel, ยฃ5 a loaf of bread. Does art matter at the moment? At first when reading your message I thought your concern was for the people of Ukraine, but it quickly became clear your concern was for your bank balance. Think what you like. Someone posted this is an art forum. This will impact markets including art. I thought id address that it also fits on art forum. Ukraine comes first concern and then what happens after that. Art is the least of most peoples worries apart from the well off moving out of stocks amd into safe havens.
|
|
|
sandinista
New Member
๐จ๏ธ 571
๐๐ป 474
April 2020
|
Vladimir Putin's invasion of Ukraine ๐บ๐ฆ, by sandinista on Feb 26, 2022 12:10:00 GMT 1, You know almost nothing about both Russians and Ukranians. Hope it will ends soon. This is an art forum first and lets keep it art related please.
I posted in the general chat forum. There are plenty of art only ones you can stick to.
You know almost nothing about both Russians and Ukranians. Hope it will ends soon. This is an art forum first and lets keep it art related please. I posted in the general chat forum. There are plenty of art only ones you can stick to.
|
|
|
Vladimir Putin's invasion of Ukraine ๐บ๐ฆ, by Daylight Robber on Feb 26, 2022 12:59:10 GMT 1, No it isnโt. What are the underlying assumptions of your statement? Ukraine was and is nowhere close to being able to join NATO. NATO would never accept Ukraine with its separatist regions. I'm not so sure about that. Yes, Ukraine isnt a member yet but they are an ally, that much is true, and I suppose you can blame France and Germany for that.
Wtf? You want to blame this on France and Germany for being allied with Ukraine?
Do we need to go into the playground bully analogies to walk this one through?
No it isnโt. What are the underlying assumptions of your statement? Ukraine was and is nowhere close to being able to join NATO. NATO would never accept Ukraine with its separatist regions. I'm not so sure about that. Yes, Ukraine isnt a member yet but they are an ally, that much is true, and I suppose you can blame France and Germany for that. Wtf? You want to blame this on France and Germany for being allied with Ukraine? Do we need to go into the playground bully analogies to walk this one through?
|
|
sandinista
New Member
๐จ๏ธ 571
๐๐ป 474
April 2020
|
Vladimir Putin's invasion of Ukraine ๐บ๐ฆ, by sandinista on Feb 26, 2022 13:02:07 GMT 1, If the russian people are against this war they need to revolt. En masse so putin cant silence it. There are no generals to oust him. This is the only way to stop this without it escalating. He wont stop at Ukraine. The f*ck is mental.
If the russian people are against this war they need to revolt. En masse so putin cant silence it. There are no generals to oust him. This is the only way to stop this without it escalating. He wont stop at Ukraine. The f*ck is mental.
|
|
seqret
Junior Member
๐จ๏ธ 2,133
๐๐ป 1,135
October 2011
|
Vladimir Putin's invasion of Ukraine ๐บ๐ฆ, by seqret on Feb 26, 2022 13:12:45 GMT 1, How can we support the conflict if both Ukraine and Russia were one country and both side speak Russian? Hence I said it's all very complicated. Of course there are exceptions on both sides (nationalists in Ukraine and dumbs in Russia). We have friends, families and relatives in both countries. So don't believe everything you see on TV. It's all very very wrong and conflict need to be stopped. What are you talking about??? Ukraine and Russia were never one country. Parts of what is now Ukraine were 'gifted' to Ukraine by former USSR leaders but Ukraine always was an independent country, albeit smaller than it is today. You seem to be believing the lies that Putin is preaching in trying to justify his appalling acts of aggression towards another country. Ukraine became independent in 1991.. before it was part of USSR. After 1991 Russia in the current form was born. We all had USSR passports so it was one country before. I was born here and remember everything. We have relatives in both countries. Ukranian people live now in Russia and Russian people also live in Ukraine now. I'm not sure what are you trying to prove me. Do I need to tell my Dad (Ukranian) that he wasn't part of the USSR and didn't meet my mother in Moscow ex USSR as well, now Russia?
"were 'gifted' to Ukraine by former USSR leaders".. part of Ukraine were gifted by ex USSR leaders yes but it was when Ukraine was PART of USSR! Also check Ukraine independent act from 24th aug of 1991.
Maybe it's a language misunderstanding but I'm not believing anyone including Putin. And this conflict need to be ended quick
How can we support the conflict if both Ukraine and Russia were one country and both side speak Russian? Hence I said it's all very complicated. Of course there are exceptions on both sides (nationalists in Ukraine and dumbs in Russia). We have friends, families and relatives in both countries. So don't believe everything you see on TV. It's all very very wrong and conflict need to be stopped. What are you talking about??? Ukraine and Russia were never one country. Parts of what is now Ukraine were 'gifted' to Ukraine by former USSR leaders but Ukraine always was an independent country, albeit smaller than it is today. You seem to be believing the lies that Putin is preaching in trying to justify his appalling acts of aggression towards another country. Ukraine became independent in 1991.. before it was part of USSR. After 1991 Russia in the current form was born. We all had USSR passports so it was one country before. I was born here and remember everything. We have relatives in both countries. Ukranian people live now in Russia and Russian people also live in Ukraine now. I'm not sure what are you trying to prove me. Do I need to tell my Dad (Ukranian) that he wasn't part of the USSR and didn't meet my mother in Moscow ex USSR as well, now Russia? "were 'gifted' to Ukraine by former USSR leaders".. part of Ukraine were gifted by ex USSR leaders yes but it was when Ukraine was PART of USSR! Also check Ukraine independent act from 24th aug of 1991. Maybe it's a language misunderstanding but I'm not believing anyone including Putin. And this conflict need to be ended quick
|
|
seqret
Junior Member
๐จ๏ธ 2,133
๐๐ป 1,135
October 2011
|
Vladimir Putin's invasion of Ukraine ๐บ๐ฆ, by seqret on Feb 26, 2022 13:18:28 GMT 1, Is there an equivalent term for โmansplainingโ, useful for when Brits and Americans try to (incorrectly) explain the nuances of Soviet history to a Russian? Thank you
Is there an equivalent term for โmansplainingโ, useful for when Brits and Americans try to (incorrectly) explain the nuances of Soviet history to a Russian? Thank you
|
|
seqret
Junior Member
๐จ๏ธ 2,133
๐๐ป 1,135
October 2011
|
Vladimir Putin's invasion of Ukraine ๐บ๐ฆ, by seqret on Feb 26, 2022 14:33:31 GMT 1, Is there an equivalent term for โmansplainingโ, useful for when Brits and Americans try to (incorrectly) explain the nuances of Soviet history to a Russian? Being Russian does not automatically mean you understand Russian history. ย Putin is the obvious example that proves my point. ย
Iโm a Russian. Ex soviet and youโre trying to explain me our history. Thats great. I give up.
Is there an equivalent term for โmansplainingโ, useful for when Brits and Americans try to (incorrectly) explain the nuances of Soviet history to a Russian? Being Russian does not automatically mean you understand Russian history. ย Putin is the obvious example that proves my point. ย Iโm a Russian. Ex soviet and youโre trying to explain me our history. Thats great. I give up.
|
|
Viennese
New Member
๐จ๏ธ 312
๐๐ป 445
October 2020
|
Vladimir Putin's invasion of Ukraine ๐บ๐ฆ, by Viennese on Feb 26, 2022 15:26:28 GMT 1, Is there an equivalent term for โmansplainingโ, useful for when Brits and Americans try to (incorrectly) explain the nuances of Soviet history to a Russian?
Does the same apply to explaining to a German or Austrian the history of the Third Reich? Are you โhistorysplainingโ by telling an Israeli about their history? Do you have to take heroin to study it? We might all be able to learn something here.
Is there an equivalent term for โmansplainingโ, useful for when Brits and Americans try to (incorrectly) explain the nuances of Soviet history to a Russian? Does the same apply to explaining to a German or Austrian the history of the Third Reich? Are you โhistorysplainingโ by telling an Israeli about their history? Do you have to take heroin to study it? We might all be able to learn something here.
|
|
Viennese
New Member
๐จ๏ธ 312
๐๐ป 445
October 2020
|
Vladimir Putin's invasion of Ukraine ๐บ๐ฆ, by Viennese on Feb 26, 2022 15:31:50 GMT 1, Being Russian does not automatically mean you understand Russian history. ย Putin is the obvious example that proves my point. ย Iโm a Russian. Ex soviet and youโre trying to explain me our history. Thats great. I give up.
Please donโt. I find this exchange very interesting. For example the things you focus on. Why does it matter whether Ukraine did or did not belong to Russia/USSR? They overwhelmingly voted to become independent. I recommend to listen to the statement of Kenya in the UN Security Council about the randomness of the drawing of borders of many states but how that doesnโt mean one canโt live in peace or have good relations or has the right to attack a neighbour.
Being Russian does not automatically mean you understand Russian history. ย Putin is the obvious example that proves my point. ย Iโm a Russian. Ex soviet and youโre trying to explain me our history. Thats great. I give up. Please donโt. I find this exchange very interesting. For example the things you focus on. Why does it matter whether Ukraine did or did not belong to Russia/USSR? They overwhelmingly voted to become independent. I recommend to listen to the statement of Kenya in the UN Security Council about the randomness of the drawing of borders of many states but how that doesnโt mean one canโt live in peace or have good relations or has the right to attack a neighbour.
|
|
|
Viennese
New Member
๐จ๏ธ 312
๐๐ป 445
October 2020
|
Vladimir Putin's invasion of Ukraine ๐บ๐ฆ, by Viennese on Feb 26, 2022 16:12:12 GMT 1, Does the same apply to explaining to a German or Austrian the history of the Third Reich? Are you โhistorysplainingโ by telling an Israeli about their history? Do you have to take heroin to study it? We might all be able to learn something here. I have no real answer to your specific questions and can only speak for myself - I am Belarusian and grew up through the end of the Soviet era, and now choose not to live in or return to my country under its current regime. I can't speak for how those who lived during the Third Reich might feel if someone triedย to explain that period of history to them in a manner that was both factually and culturally incorrect. And lastly, I have not found heroin useful for any of my educational endeavours, but each to their own.ย
Glad you also found no use in heroin ๐
I agree with you that we should never speak for those that actually lived through experiences on some level but there is a difference in speaking for someone and speaking about historical events. A big problem with historical events is framing. And somebody who lived through an event is just as and oftentimes even more susceptible to falling pray to bias, propaganda and illegitimate framing. Myself and the history of my country of course included.
My point is that the way this discussion here is framed, that Russia and Ukraine were one country is feeding an assumption that I believe is wrong and serves in part to relativize what is happening. I gather that everybody hear knows that Ukraine belonged to the Soviet Union but what is omitted is that the Soviet Union was created as a federal state, a federation of national units very much acknowledging the fact that Ukranians wanted to be/were a nation. Ukranians called for independece after the collapse of the Russian empire in 1917 and even before that there were efforts to that end. Ukraine in a way was already there before the Soviet Union was created.
The point is though that all of this just masks the fact that Ukranians overwhelmingly voted to become independent, became independent in a legitimate way and more recently revolted to again chose a different future for themselves and look to the West. Something Putin simply canโt handle.
Does the same apply to explaining to a German or Austrian the history of the Third Reich? Are you โhistorysplainingโ by telling an Israeli about their history? Do you have to take heroin to study it? We might all be able to learn something here. I have no real answer to your specific questions and can only speak for myself - I am Belarusian and grew up through the end of the Soviet era, and now choose not to live in or return to my country under its current regime. I can't speak for how those who lived during the Third Reich might feel if someone triedย to explain that period of history to them in a manner that was both factually and culturally incorrect. And lastly, I have not found heroin useful for any of my educational endeavours, but each to their own.ย Glad you also found no use in heroin ๐ I agree with you that we should never speak for those that actually lived through experiences on some level but there is a difference in speaking for someone and speaking about historical events. A big problem with historical events is framing. And somebody who lived through an event is just as and oftentimes even more susceptible to falling pray to bias, propaganda and illegitimate framing. Myself and the history of my country of course included. My point is that the way this discussion here is framed, that Russia and Ukraine were one country is feeding an assumption that I believe is wrong and serves in part to relativize what is happening. I gather that everybody hear knows that Ukraine belonged to the Soviet Union but what is omitted is that the Soviet Union was created as a federal state, a federation of national units very much acknowledging the fact that Ukranians wanted to be/were a nation. Ukranians called for independece after the collapse of the Russian empire in 1917 and even before that there were efforts to that end. Ukraine in a way was already there before the Soviet Union was created. The point is though that all of this just masks the fact that Ukranians overwhelmingly voted to become independent, became independent in a legitimate way and more recently revolted to again chose a different future for themselves and look to the West. Something Putin simply canโt handle.
|
|
seqret
Junior Member
๐จ๏ธ 2,133
๐๐ป 1,135
October 2011
|
Vladimir Putin's invasion of Ukraine ๐บ๐ฆ, by seqret on Feb 26, 2022 17:06:35 GMT 1, Iโm a Russian. Ex soviet and youโre trying to explain me our history. Thats great. I give up. Your apparent claim that all Russians know more about Russian history than any non-Russian is ridiculous. You are simply repeating the lies that Putin has put in your head. Please stop.. Putin didn't put anything in my head.
Iโm a Russian. Ex soviet and youโre trying to explain me our history. Thats great. I give up. Your apparent claim that all Russians know more about Russian history than any non-Russian is ridiculous. You are simply repeating the lies that Putin has put in your head. Please stop.. Putin didn't put anything in my head.
|
|
seqret
Junior Member
๐จ๏ธ 2,133
๐๐ป 1,135
October 2011
|
Vladimir Putin's invasion of Ukraine ๐บ๐ฆ, by seqret on Feb 26, 2022 17:09:39 GMT 1, All I'm trying to say that we were part of one big country once.. noone put that in my head. I lived in that country myself.
I want Ukraine be independant, I want Ukrainian gov stop what they doing in Donetsk. I want Russian gov stop as well. And I don't want to see people saying bad things about Russian citizens.. you can say whatever you want about Russian gov but not citizens. Thats it. This is all wrong
Peace
All I'm trying to say that we were part of one big country once.. noone put that in my head. I lived in that country myself.
I want Ukraine be independant, I want Ukrainian gov stop what they doing in Donetsk. I want Russian gov stop as well. And I don't want to see people saying bad things about Russian citizens.. you can say whatever you want about Russian gov but not citizens. Thats it. This is all wrong
Peace
|
|
Viennese
New Member
๐จ๏ธ 312
๐๐ป 445
October 2020
|
Vladimir Putin's invasion of Ukraine ๐บ๐ฆ, by Viennese on Feb 26, 2022 17:19:26 GMT 1, All I'm trying to say that we were part of one big country once.. noone put that in my head. I lived in that country myself. I want Ukraine be independant, I want Ukrainian gov stop what they doing in Donetsk. I want Russian gov stop as well. And I don't want to see people saying bad things about Russian citizens.. you can say whatever you want about Russian gov but not citizens. Thats it. This is all wrong Peace
I hear you but I donโt think most people mean Russians when they say โRussia did xyzโ. It almost always means the goverment. Just the same as when you read the โUSโ or any other country.
What I would be interested in is what you think exactly the UA government did in Donetsk and Luhansk? Would you say that life for the inhabitants of the so called โrepublicsโ now is better than before?
All I'm trying to say that we were part of one big country once.. noone put that in my head. I lived in that country myself. I want Ukraine be independant, I want Ukrainian gov stop what they doing in Donetsk. I want Russian gov stop as well. And I don't want to see people saying bad things about Russian citizens.. you can say whatever you want about Russian gov but not citizens. Thats it. This is all wrong Peace I hear you but I donโt think most people mean Russians when they say โRussia did xyzโ. It almost always means the goverment. Just the same as when you read the โUSโ or any other country. What I would be interested in is what you think exactly the UA government did in Donetsk and Luhansk? Would you say that life for the inhabitants of the so called โrepublicsโ now is better than before?
|
|
seqret
Junior Member
๐จ๏ธ 2,133
๐๐ป 1,135
October 2011
|
Vladimir Putin's invasion of Ukraine ๐บ๐ฆ, by seqret on Feb 26, 2022 17:31:22 GMT 1, All I'm trying to say that we were part of one big country once.. noone put that in my head. I lived in that country myself. I want Ukraine be independant, I want Ukrainian gov stop what they doing in Donetsk. I want Russian gov stop as well. And I don't want to see people saying bad things about Russian citizens.. you can say whatever you want about Russian gov but not citizens. Thats it. This is all wrong Peace I hear you but I donโt think most people mean Russians when they say โRussia did xyzโ. It almost always means the goverment. Just the same as when you read the โUSโ or any other country. What I would be interested in is what you think exactly the UA government did in Donetsk and Luhansk? Would you say that life for the inhabitants of the so called โrepublicsโ now is better than before? Life in Donetsk and Luhansk is like in hell since 2014. And thats coming not from TV. I'm not sure if my english is good enough to express my thoughts but in short after Ukraine crisis and protests, Donbass decided to be independent. Almost 8 years later it's still a conflict there. This need to be stopped as well.
Do you remember what happened in Odessa in 2014?
All I'm trying to say that we were part of one big country once.. noone put that in my head. I lived in that country myself. I want Ukraine be independant, I want Ukrainian gov stop what they doing in Donetsk. I want Russian gov stop as well. And I don't want to see people saying bad things about Russian citizens.. you can say whatever you want about Russian gov but not citizens. Thats it. This is all wrong Peace I hear you but I donโt think most people mean Russians when they say โRussia did xyzโ. It almost always means the goverment. Just the same as when you read the โUSโ or any other country. What I would be interested in is what you think exactly the UA government did in Donetsk and Luhansk? Would you say that life for the inhabitants of the so called โrepublicsโ now is better than before? Life in Donetsk and Luhansk is like in hell since 2014. And thats coming not from TV. I'm not sure if my english is good enough to express my thoughts but in short after Ukraine crisis and protests, Donbass decided to be independent. Almost 8 years later it's still a conflict there. This need to be stopped as well. Do you remember what happened in Odessa in 2014?
|
|
|
Vladimir Putin's invasion of Ukraine ๐บ๐ฆ, by Peter Bengtsen on Feb 26, 2022 18:04:02 GMT 1, I hear you but I donโt think most people mean Russians when they say โRussia did xyzโ. It almost always means the goverment. Just the same as when you read the โUSโ or any other country. What I would be interested in is what you think exactly the UA government did in Donetsk and Luhansk? Would you say that life for the inhabitants of the so called โrepublicsโ now is better than before? Life in Donetsk and Luhansk is like in hell since 2014. And thats coming not from TV. I'm not sure if my english is good enough to express my thoughts but in short after Ukraine crisis and protests, Donbass decided to be independent. Almost 8 years later it's still a conflict there. This need to be stopped as well. Do you remember what happened in Odessa in 2014?
Anyone who reads this should be aware that the above "summary" of events is both inaccurate and grossly misleading.
The referendum about independence was not carried out until Russian-backed separatists had taken control of Donetsk by brute force. This move lead thousands of pro-Ukranian inhabitants of the city to flee. On this background, it is no wonder the illegitimate referendum (which has not been internationally recognised) resulted in a vote for independence.
It is true that fighting has been ongoing in these regions, as Ukraine has tried to take back the territory that has de facto been occupied by Russia for almost 8 years. Oh, and before you begin, seqret , I was in Donetsk in 2014.
The Ukranian people kicked out their Russian puppet president in 2014 during the Revolution of Dignity in Kyiv. More than 100 people died to secure democratic and free elections in Ukraine.
Although there will doubtless be loss of human life, if the Russian population is really against the actions of Putin, the Russian people need to take responsibility and rise up to remove him. The time for words and silent protests is over.
I hear you but I donโt think most people mean Russians when they say โRussia did xyzโ. It almost always means the goverment. Just the same as when you read the โUSโ or any other country. What I would be interested in is what you think exactly the UA government did in Donetsk and Luhansk? Would you say that life for the inhabitants of the so called โrepublicsโ now is better than before? Life in Donetsk and Luhansk is like in hell since 2014. And thats coming not from TV. I'm not sure if my english is good enough to express my thoughts but in short after Ukraine crisis and protests, Donbass decided to be independent. Almost 8 years later it's still a conflict there. This need to be stopped as well. Do you remember what happened in Odessa in 2014? Anyone who reads this should be aware that the above "summary" of events is both inaccurate and grossly misleading.
The referendum about independence was not carried out until Russian-backed separatists had taken control of Donetsk by brute force. This move lead thousands of pro-Ukranian inhabitants of the city to flee. On this background, it is no wonder the illegitimate referendum (which has not been internationally recognised) resulted in a vote for independence.
It is true that fighting has been ongoing in these regions, as Ukraine has tried to take back the territory that has de facto been occupied by Russia for almost 8 years. Oh, and before you begin, seqret , I was in Donetsk in 2014.
The Ukranian people kicked out their Russian puppet president in 2014 during the Revolution of Dignity in Kyiv. More than 100 people died to secure democratic and free elections in Ukraine.
Although there will doubtless be loss of human life, if the Russian population is really against the actions of Putin, the Russian people need to take responsibility and rise up to remove him. The time for words and silent protests is over.
|
|
seqret
Junior Member
๐จ๏ธ 2,133
๐๐ป 1,135
October 2011
|
Vladimir Putin's invasion of Ukraine ๐บ๐ฆ, by seqret on Feb 26, 2022 18:10:40 GMT 1, Life in Donetsk and Luhansk is like in hell since 2014. And thats coming not from TV. I'm not sure if my english is good enough to express my thoughts but in short after Ukraine crisis and protests, Donbass decided to be independent. Almost 8 years later it's still a conflict there. This need to be stopped as well. Do you remember what happened in Odessa in 2014? Anyone who reads this should be aware that the above "summary" of events is both inaccurate and grossly misleading.
The referendum about independence was not carried out until Russian-backed separatists had taken control of Donetsk by brute force. This move lead thousands of pro-Ukranian inhabitants of the city to flee. On this background, it is no wonder the illegitimate referendum (which has not been internationally recognised) resulted in a vote for independence.
It is true that fighting has been ongoing in these regions, as Ukraine has tried to take back the territory that has de facto been occupied by Russia for almost 8 years. Oh, and before you begin, seqret , I was in Donetsk in 2014.
The Ukranian people kicked out their Russian puppet president in 2014 during the Revolution of Dignity in Kyiv. More than 100 people died to secure democratic and free elections in Ukraine.
Although there will doubtless be loss of human life, if the Russian population is really against the actions of Putin, the Russian people need to take responsibility and rise up to remove him. The time for words and silent protests is over.
I'm not beginning anything.. I think I wrote almost the same but too short (not enough english). I'm not trying to mislead, blame or defend anyone. I'm just tired of all these conflicts.
And I have your book btw
Life in Donetsk and Luhansk is like in hell since 2014. And thats coming not from TV. I'm not sure if my english is good enough to express my thoughts but in short after Ukraine crisis and protests, Donbass decided to be independent. Almost 8 years later it's still a conflict there. This need to be stopped as well. Do you remember what happened in Odessa in 2014? Anyone who reads this should be aware that the above "summary" of events is both inaccurate and grossly misleading.
The referendum about independence was not carried out until Russian-backed separatists had taken control of Donetsk by brute force. This move lead thousands of pro-Ukranian inhabitants of the city to flee. On this background, it is no wonder the illegitimate referendum (which has not been internationally recognised) resulted in a vote for independence.
It is true that fighting has been ongoing in these regions, as Ukraine has tried to take back the territory that has de facto been occupied by Russia for almost 8 years. Oh, and before you begin, seqret , I was in Donetsk in 2014.
The Ukranian people kicked out their Russian puppet president in 2014 during the Revolution of Dignity in Kyiv. More than 100 people died to secure democratic and free elections in Ukraine.
Although there will doubtless be loss of human life, if the Russian population is really against the actions of Putin, the Russian people need to take responsibility and rise up to remove him. The time for words and silent protests is over.
I'm not beginning anything.. I think I wrote almost the same but too short (not enough english). I'm not trying to mislead, blame or defend anyone. I'm just tired of all these conflicts. And I have your book btw
|
|
Viennese
New Member
๐จ๏ธ 312
๐๐ป 445
October 2020
|
Vladimir Putin's invasion of Ukraine ๐บ๐ฆ, by Viennese on Feb 26, 2022 18:22:02 GMT 1, I hear you but I donโt think most people mean Russians when they say โRussia did xyzโ. It almost always means the goverment. Just the same as when you read the โUSโ or any other country. What I would be interested in is what you think exactly the UA government did in Donetsk and Luhansk? Would you say that life for the inhabitants of the so called โrepublicsโ now is better than before? Life in Donetsk and Luhansk is like in hell since 2014. And thats coming not from TV. I'm not sure if my english is good enough to express my thoughts but in short after Ukraine crisis and protests, Donbass decided to be independent. Almost 8 years later it's still a conflict there. This need to be stopped as well. Do you remember what happened in Odessa in 2014?
I remember Odessa being an utter tragedy! There was immense brutality and I read about a commission of experts, journalists and activists that came to the conclusion that it was a chain of events that led to it that started with provocations from pro-Russian activists. In the end, everybody is a victim also in the inner-Ukranian conflict but letโs not be blind to the agitation that was and is caused by Russia here too. We also have a right-wing party in my country that sporadically wants to hand out passports to a โpart of our nationโ that now are citizens of another country. It is not right to do that. We have international law to prevent such things from happening, otherwise the whole world would be at war because most of the countries in the world have arbitrarily drawn borders. If minorities are discriminated against then that is of course not justified and needs to be remedied. I believe it started around restrictions on the Russian language in Ukraine. But it is not ok to plunge a country or part of it into war over it. My country also has a long history of issues with minority languages and it took a while to put up signs in both languages where appropriate, it was a painful process until it finally happened and I am ashamed it took so long but no killings would have ever been justified.
Be that as it may, of course nothing justifies the Russian invasion. I agree, the people in Donetsk and Luhansk have it worse than people in Ukraine or in Russia. But I donโt see Russia doing anything against the totalitarian rule there.
I hear you but I donโt think most people mean Russians when they say โRussia did xyzโ. It almost always means the goverment. Just the same as when you read the โUSโ or any other country. What I would be interested in is what you think exactly the UA government did in Donetsk and Luhansk? Would you say that life for the inhabitants of the so called โrepublicsโ now is better than before? Life in Donetsk and Luhansk is like in hell since 2014. And thats coming not from TV. I'm not sure if my english is good enough to express my thoughts but in short after Ukraine crisis and protests, Donbass decided to be independent. Almost 8 years later it's still a conflict there. This need to be stopped as well. Do you remember what happened in Odessa in 2014? I remember Odessa being an utter tragedy! There was immense brutality and I read about a commission of experts, journalists and activists that came to the conclusion that it was a chain of events that led to it that started with provocations from pro-Russian activists. In the end, everybody is a victim also in the inner-Ukranian conflict but letโs not be blind to the agitation that was and is caused by Russia here too. We also have a right-wing party in my country that sporadically wants to hand out passports to a โpart of our nationโ that now are citizens of another country. It is not right to do that. We have international law to prevent such things from happening, otherwise the whole world would be at war because most of the countries in the world have arbitrarily drawn borders. If minorities are discriminated against then that is of course not justified and needs to be remedied. I believe it started around restrictions on the Russian language in Ukraine. But it is not ok to plunge a country or part of it into war over it. My country also has a long history of issues with minority languages and it took a while to put up signs in both languages where appropriate, it was a painful process until it finally happened and I am ashamed it took so long but no killings would have ever been justified. Be that as it may, of course nothing justifies the Russian invasion. I agree, the people in Donetsk and Luhansk have it worse than people in Ukraine or in Russia. But I donโt see Russia doing anything against the totalitarian rule there.
|
|
|
seqret
Junior Member
๐จ๏ธ 2,133
๐๐ป 1,135
October 2011
|
Vladimir Putin's invasion of Ukraine ๐บ๐ฆ, by seqret on Feb 26, 2022 18:52:11 GMT 1, I'm fully agree with you @viennnese on everything. And restrictions on Russian language was a really bad idea cos there are a lot of Ukranian people who don't know Ukraninan language at all. Where're you from btw?
Also I want to ask your opinion re Yugoslavia. Was it aggression?
I'm fully agree with you @viennnese on everything. And restrictions on Russian language was a really bad idea cos there are a lot of Ukranian people who don't know Ukraninan language at all. Where're you from btw?
Also I want to ask your opinion re Yugoslavia. Was it aggression?
|
|
STP
New Member
๐จ๏ธ 328
๐๐ป 900
February 2022
|
Vladimir Putin's invasion of Ukraine ๐บ๐ฆ, by STP on Feb 26, 2022 22:27:52 GMT 1, Putinโs a dangerous bayard. He thought he was holding all the cards and could hold Ukraine (and indeed the West) hostage, but he wasnโt, heโs actually operating from a position of severe weakness, the worst of which being invasion was his last resort.
Ukraine used to be a soviet republic, and for most of its independence its leaders operated in close association with Russia, but in 2013 the Ukrainian people realised that a political and economic dependence on Russia was a road to nowhere and they rose up and demanded closer ties with the EU. Putin panicked at this and gunned down protestors.
That backfired big time and Putinโs allies were run out of the country and the nation elected ardent pro-Europe and pro-US leadership. In response, Putin invaded Crimea and eastern Ukraine, which only served to harden anti-Russian sentiments.
As we saw earlier this month, Putin remained determined to control Ukraine, so he moved 150,000 troops to the border and threatened a full-on invasion, hoping this threat would collapse Ukraineโs government, and/or create fissures within NATO to weaken the alliance, resulting in the West folding and agreeing to his demands.
But none of that has happened, in fact quite the opposite. The Zelensky government hasnโt fallen, the West have rallied to support Ukraineโs government, NATO and Europe have come together to support Ukraineโs sovereignty, and Putinโs list of demands have gone nowhere. Nobody gave in.
Now, faced with this reality, Putin has only two ways out: back down or continue with his expensive and potentially disastrous invasion of the largest country in Europe. Should he choose to continue, it will likely be long and deadly, the Ukrainian people are not going to submit. And the sanctions from the rest of the world will be equally devastating, nothing at all like the relatively mild sanctions Russia has previously endured.
The combination of the cost of the war and the cost of the sanctions are going to seriously threaten Putinโs grip on power, and all for what? To force Ukraine back into Russiaโs orbit against Ukraineโs wishes? A nation that used to rely on Russia willingly? All of this just to achieve pre-2013 status quo but with thousands dead and a Russian economy in ruins?
Heโs already lost the war.
Putinโs a dangerous bayard. He thought he was holding all the cards and could hold Ukraine (and indeed the West) hostage, but he wasnโt, heโs actually operating from a position of severe weakness, the worst of which being invasion was his last resort.
Ukraine used to be a soviet republic, and for most of its independence its leaders operated in close association with Russia, but in 2013 the Ukrainian people realised that a political and economic dependence on Russia was a road to nowhere and they rose up and demanded closer ties with the EU. Putin panicked at this and gunned down protestors.
That backfired big time and Putinโs allies were run out of the country and the nation elected ardent pro-Europe and pro-US leadership. In response, Putin invaded Crimea and eastern Ukraine, which only served to harden anti-Russian sentiments.
As we saw earlier this month, Putin remained determined to control Ukraine, so he moved 150,000 troops to the border and threatened a full-on invasion, hoping this threat would collapse Ukraineโs government, and/or create fissures within NATO to weaken the alliance, resulting in the West folding and agreeing to his demands.
But none of that has happened, in fact quite the opposite. The Zelensky government hasnโt fallen, the West have rallied to support Ukraineโs government, NATO and Europe have come together to support Ukraineโs sovereignty, and Putinโs list of demands have gone nowhere. Nobody gave in.
Now, faced with this reality, Putin has only two ways out: back down or continue with his expensive and potentially disastrous invasion of the largest country in Europe. Should he choose to continue, it will likely be long and deadly, the Ukrainian people are not going to submit. And the sanctions from the rest of the world will be equally devastating, nothing at all like the relatively mild sanctions Russia has previously endured.
The combination of the cost of the war and the cost of the sanctions are going to seriously threaten Putinโs grip on power, and all for what? To force Ukraine back into Russiaโs orbit against Ukraineโs wishes? A nation that used to rely on Russia willingly? All of this just to achieve pre-2013 status quo but with thousands dead and a Russian economy in ruins?
Heโs already lost the war.
|
|
Georgie Poppit
Junior Member
๐จ๏ธ 1,558
๐๐ป 1,674
February 2021
|
Vladimir Putin's invasion of Ukraine ๐บ๐ฆ, by Georgie Poppit on Feb 27, 2022 13:25:59 GMT 1, Interesting to see if there is clear pro Ukrainian messages at the cup final today. Iโm guessing probably not from Chelski
Interesting to see if there is clear pro Ukrainian messages at the cup final today. Iโm guessing probably not from Chelski
|
|
STP
New Member
๐จ๏ธ 328
๐๐ป 900
February 2022
|
Vladimir Putin's invasion of Ukraine ๐บ๐ฆ, by STP on Feb 27, 2022 14:17:00 GMT 1, Lest we forget...
In 2019 Trump withheld a $400 million congressionally mandated military aid package to Ukraine, demanding President Zelensky dig up shit on former Vice President Joe Biden and his son Hunter to assist Trump's re-election.
Donald Trump was impeached for the attempted extortion.
Lest we forget... In 2019 Trump withheld a $400 million congressionally mandated military aid package to Ukraine, demanding President Zelensky dig up shit on former Vice President Joe Biden and his son Hunter to assist Trump's re-election. Donald Trump was impeached for the attempted extortion.
|
|
timson
New Member
๐จ๏ธ 144
๐๐ป 48
December 2019
|
Vladimir Putin's invasion of Ukraine ๐บ๐ฆ, by timson on Feb 27, 2022 17:17:37 GMT 1, Lest we forget... In 2019 Trump withheld a $400 million congressionally mandated military aid package to Ukraine, demanding President Zelensky dig up shit on former Vice President Joe Biden and his son Hunter to assist Trump's re-election. Donald Trump was impeached for the attempted extortion.
Tons of connections between Trunp and Ukraine: - Trumpโs campaign chief (Paul Manafort) was a consultant and lobbyist for over a decade for Putinโs man in Ukraine, former President Yanukovych. Itโs actually what he went to prison for, hiding from the IRS the millions he received from Yanukovych. - As Trumpโs chief, Manafort successfully lobbied for the removal of Ukrainian Aid from the 2016 RNC Platform. This was surprising at the time as aid to Ukraine had been a standard part of GOP platforms of the past. - Via his previous work in Ukraine, Manafort met Konstantin Kilimnik. Manafort passed internal Trump campaign polling info and electoral plans to Kilimnik, who it turns out was a Russian spy. - After the election, Trumpโs lawyer (Rudy Giuliani) began looking for dirt for on presumed 2020 opponent Joe Biden in Ukraine. Giuliani and his associates began a smear campaign against the US ambassador to Ukraine (Marie Yovanovitch) because she was undermining their efforts there, ultimately leading to Trump removing her. - Shortly thereafter, the infamous blackmail call between Trump and Zelensky happened.
Lest we forget... In 2019 Trump withheld a $400 million congressionally mandated military aid package to Ukraine, demanding President Zelensky dig up shit on former Vice President Joe Biden and his son Hunter to assist Trump's re-election. Donald Trump was impeached for the attempted extortion. Tons of connections between Trunp and Ukraine: - Trumpโs campaign chief (Paul Manafort) was a consultant and lobbyist for over a decade for Putinโs man in Ukraine, former President Yanukovych. Itโs actually what he went to prison for, hiding from the IRS the millions he received from Yanukovych. - As Trumpโs chief, Manafort successfully lobbied for the removal of Ukrainian Aid from the 2016 RNC Platform. This was surprising at the time as aid to Ukraine had been a standard part of GOP platforms of the past. - Via his previous work in Ukraine, Manafort met Konstantin Kilimnik. Manafort passed internal Trump campaign polling info and electoral plans to Kilimnik, who it turns out was a Russian spy. - After the election, Trumpโs lawyer (Rudy Giuliani) began looking for dirt for on presumed 2020 opponent Joe Biden in Ukraine. Giuliani and his associates began a smear campaign against the US ambassador to Ukraine (Marie Yovanovitch) because she was undermining their efforts there, ultimately leading to Trump removing her. - Shortly thereafter, the infamous blackmail call between Trump and Zelensky happened.
|
|
Georgie Poppit
Junior Member
๐จ๏ธ 1,558
๐๐ป 1,674
February 2021
|
Vladimir Putin's invasion of Ukraine ๐บ๐ฆ, by Georgie Poppit on Feb 27, 2022 17:23:05 GMT 1, So howโs all this going to end?
So howโs all this going to end?
|
|
mojo
Junior Member
๐จ๏ธ 2,185
๐๐ป 3,709
May 2014
|
Vladimir Putin's invasion of Ukraine ๐บ๐ฆ, by mojo on Feb 27, 2022 18:53:50 GMT 1, So howโs all this going to end? Hopefully with Putin shooting himself through his bigoted head as soon as possible since he is incapable of admitting defeat.
It is high time 'our global leaders' were phycologically profiled before given any form of power regardless of how rich they are, since many deserve to be long term residents in asylums for the dangerously disturbed.
So howโs all this going to end? Hopefully with Putin shooting himself through his bigoted head as soon as possible since he is incapable of admitting defeat. It is high time 'our global leaders' were phycologically profiled before given any form of power regardless of how rich they are, since many deserve to be long term residents in asylums for the dangerously disturbed.
|
|
moron
Junior Member
๐จ๏ธ 2,711
๐๐ป 1,051
September 2017
|
Vladimir Putin's invasion of Ukraine ๐บ๐ฆ, by moron on Feb 27, 2022 19:49:53 GMT 1, So howโs all this going to end? I don't know but there's some scary parallels between Putin and the rise of Hitler in 1930s Germany. I'd compare Putin more similar to Stalin than Hitler.
So howโs all this going to end? I don't know but there's some scary parallels between Putin and the rise of Hitler in 1930s Germany. I'd compare Putin more similar to Stalin than Hitler.
|
|