gbh
Junior Member
Posts • 2,595
Likes • 14
May 2006
|
|
|
rickyc
New Member
Posts • 142
Likes • 0
September 2006
|
Art-O-Meter, by rickyc on Jan 4, 2007 10:38:44 GMT 1, The idea is quite good, but not that realistic.
I can go to the Tate Modern with my friend, breeze through a lot of it and stop and enjoy the images I like the most for a minute or 2.
She, on the other hand, stops and looks at everything for an age, whether she likes it or not - just to scope the full meaning behind the image (while I'm standing behind her screaming 'JUST MOVE ON! ITS A CANVAS, PAINTED BLUE!!!')
I think a fairer system would be (best case I can think of) an IMDB type rating, where EVERYONE gives it a rating out of 5 or 10, then it will give an overall average (3.4 out of 234 votes)
Just my thoughts as a marketer, but I do really like the concept behind 'vote-tallied art'. It would be interesting to walk into a gallery and see what other people enjoy
The idea is quite good, but not that realistic.
I can go to the Tate Modern with my friend, breeze through a lot of it and stop and enjoy the images I like the most for a minute or 2.
She, on the other hand, stops and looks at everything for an age, whether she likes it or not - just to scope the full meaning behind the image (while I'm standing behind her screaming 'JUST MOVE ON! ITS A CANVAS, PAINTED BLUE!!!')
I think a fairer system would be (best case I can think of) an IMDB type rating, where EVERYONE gives it a rating out of 5 or 10, then it will give an overall average (3.4 out of 234 votes)
Just my thoughts as a marketer, but I do really like the concept behind 'vote-tallied art'. It would be interesting to walk into a gallery and see what other people enjoy
|
|
|
|
Art-O-Meter, by headphonesex on Jan 4, 2007 11:58:57 GMT 1, The trouble is, in the kind of galleries that might install this system, people stand for ages in front of the 'famous' paintings rather than the 'good' paintings.
The trouble is, in the kind of galleries that might install this system, people stand for ages in front of the 'famous' paintings rather than the 'good' paintings.
|
|
|
|
Art-O-Meter, by corblimeylimey on Jan 4, 2007 12:25:24 GMT 1, Art near the free drinks on the opening night is going to turn out to be the best! ;D
Art near the free drinks on the opening night is going to turn out to be the best! ;D
|
|
|
|
Art-O-Meter, by numusic on Jan 4, 2007 12:35:21 GMT 1, Art near the free drinks on the opening night is going to turn out to be the best! ;D
LOL.. good point.
Art near the free drinks on the opening night is going to turn out to be the best! ;D LOL.. good point. |
|
|
|
Art-O-Meter, by irf2112 on Jan 4, 2007 16:28:50 GMT 1, if you like it you like it... if you dont you dont...
if you like it you like it... if you dont you dont...
|
|
|
|
beyond
New Member
Posts • 131
Likes • 1
December 2006
|
Art-O-Meter, by beyond on Jan 4, 2007 16:57:04 GMT 1, if you like it you like it... if you dont you dont...
agree i hate the way everything is fed into some computer
destroy all computers (except my laptop)
if you like it you like it... if you dont you dont... agree i hate the way everything is fed into some computer destroy all computers (except my laptop) |
|
BK83
Junior Member
Posts • 1,604
Likes • 10
October 2006
|
Art-O-Meter, by BK83 on Jan 4, 2007 16:58:04 GMT 1, The trouble is, in the kind of galleries that might install this system, people stand for ages in front of the 'famous' paintings rather than the 'good' paintings.
Not to mention what if someone doesn't understand what the painting is/means and stands there for ages just to try and figure it out. that would actually be a bad painting because it did not properly convey its message.
The trouble is, in the kind of galleries that might install this system, people stand for ages in front of the 'famous' paintings rather than the 'good' paintings. Not to mention what if someone doesn't understand what the painting is/means and stands there for ages just to try and figure it out. that would actually be a bad painting because it did not properly convey its message. |
|
|
|
Art-O-Meter, by Daniel Silk on Jan 4, 2007 17:17:07 GMT 1,
I think its a pretty good idea ;D
Its not so much about if the people like the artwork, its more about does it make them think and do they find it interesting  they might think its crap! but they have taken that time to think about it  ;D
Most of us have Banksy's and such on our walls, and the ones that catch people eye and they ask you about are not always the ones they like the most, they would probably say they would never buy anything like that themselves, but the one they really liked would be the one they just walked straight past.
I think its a pretty good idea ;D Its not so much about if the people like the artwork, its more about does it make them think and do they find it interesting they might think its crap! but they have taken that time to think about it ;D Most of us have Banksy's and such on our walls, and the ones that catch people eye and they ask you about are not always the ones they like the most, they would probably say they would never buy anything like that themselves, but the one they really liked would be the one they just walked straight past. |
|
|
|
Art-O-Meter, by slowmo on Jan 4, 2007 17:34:11 GMT 1, Most of us have Banksy's and such on our walls, and the ones that catch people eye and they ask you about are not always the ones they like the most, they would probably say they would never buy anything like that themselves, but the one they really liked would be the one they just walked straight past
Interestingly, if I had an art o meter over christmas with all the friends and family I had over, flags would have been the most popular, pretty much everyone asked who had done it and a few wanted one. Granted however that I only have 3 banksy's on the walls at the moment
Most of us have Banksy's and such on our walls, and the ones that catch people eye and they ask you about are not always the ones they like the most, they would probably say they would never buy anything like that themselves, but the one they really liked would be the one they just walked straight past
Interestingly, if I had an art o meter over christmas with all the friends and family I had over, flags would have been the most popular, pretty much everyone asked who had done it and a few wanted one. Granted however that I only have 3 banksy's on the walls at the moment
|
|
|
|
Art-O-Meter, by numusic on Jan 4, 2007 23:15:49 GMT 1, The trouble is, in the kind of galleries that might install this system, people stand for ages in front of the 'famous' paintings rather than the 'good' paintings. Not to mention what if someone doesn't understand what the painting is/means and stands there for ages just to try and figure it out. that would actually be a bad painting because it did not properly convey its message.
or a stupid person I'm tired of the 'i like what i like' justification for not liking difficult art. They're not cartoons !
The trouble is, in the kind of galleries that might install this system, people stand for ages in front of the 'famous' paintings rather than the 'good' paintings. Not to mention what if someone doesn't understand what the painting is/means and stands there for ages just to try and figure it out. that would actually be a bad painting because it did not properly convey its message. or a stupid person I'm tired of the 'i like what i like' justification for not liking difficult art. They're not cartoons ! |
|
LoveRat
New Member
Posts • 467
Likes • 0
January 2006
|
Art-O-Meter, by LoveRat on Jan 5, 2007 0:34:20 GMT 1, if you like it you like it... if you dont you dont...
If you like you like it .......if you don't understand it you don't ;D
if you like it you like it... if you dont you dont... If you like you like it .......if you don't understand it you don't ;D |
|
they might think its crap! but they have taken that time to think about it 
;D
