eddiedangerous
Junior Member
Posts โข 1,600
Likes โข 40
October 2007
|
Must watch TV - The Mona Lisa Curse C4 6.30pm, by eddiedangerous on Sept 22, 2008 7:29:27 GMT 1, It really surprises me how many people agreed with Hughes. Whilst I can see that many of his arguments were superficially attractive - art is all about money and consumerism and not about the art I think that there is a real snobbery underlying his critique. Hughes' halcyon era for the art world seems to be the 1960's pre warhol. It is worth reminding ourselves that at this time art was an almost exclusively eliteist pastime. Visitor numbers at galleries and museums were a tiny percentage of what they are now and the ownership of art was restricted to a tiny elite. Because of this any new art movement tended to suffer from critical disdain and public humiliation. The minimalists particularly suffered at the hands of the popular press - Carl Andre's brick etc etc. Then along came the pop artists and the mass production of works of art that were accessible and fun. And people started to recognise that they could have something more than an athena poster on their wall. They actually started to visit galleries and museums and appreciate art. Then, in the UK we had sensation at the royal academy. Here was a new vibrant, young scene which people could identify. Sure they didn't like all the artwork but suddenly they felt that artists were actually saying something that they could understand and appreciate. It still got criticised in the Daily Mail of course but gradually the public opinion of contemporary art began to change. So now you have a situation where contemporary art is one of the largest growing leisure pursuits in the western world. More people visit the Tate Modern each year than visit Alton Towers. And of course some people want to own this art and display it on their walls. And what is wrong with that??? Perhaps we should all go back to Hughes halcyon time. If we did though this forum wouldn't exist and [glow=red,2,300]most of the members on it would probably have the 21st century equivalent of athena posters on their wall[/glow].
um, drums fingers looking around flat. pictures on walls is the athena of the 21st century!!!
i liked the show however I think similar distain has always been apparent throughout time with new artistic movements. very few new art movements have been embraced by their contemporary audience, and if they had the means to replicate images back in the high rennaissance I am sure they would have done. technology is one of the main driving forces in art as it is in most sectors. and with new technology comes new forms of art. i think he wouldrather we all had blank walls, and only had museum walls to admire!!! looking forward to parts 2 and 3 though!!!!
It really surprises me how many people agreed with Hughes. Whilst I can see that many of his arguments were superficially attractive - art is all about money and consumerism and not about the art I think that there is a real snobbery underlying his critique. Hughes' halcyon era for the art world seems to be the 1960's pre warhol. It is worth reminding ourselves that at this time art was an almost exclusively eliteist pastime. Visitor numbers at galleries and museums were a tiny percentage of what they are now and the ownership of art was restricted to a tiny elite. Because of this any new art movement tended to suffer from critical disdain and public humiliation. The minimalists particularly suffered at the hands of the popular press - Carl Andre's brick etc etc. Then along came the pop artists and the mass production of works of art that were accessible and fun. And people started to recognise that they could have something more than an athena poster on their wall. They actually started to visit galleries and museums and appreciate art. Then, in the UK we had sensation at the royal academy. Here was a new vibrant, young scene which people could identify. Sure they didn't like all the artwork but suddenly they felt that artists were actually saying something that they could understand and appreciate. It still got criticised in the Daily Mail of course but gradually the public opinion of contemporary art began to change. So now you have a situation where contemporary art is one of the largest growing leisure pursuits in the western world. More people visit the Tate Modern each year than visit Alton Towers. And of course some people want to own this art and display it on their walls. And what is wrong with that??? Perhaps we should all go back to Hughes halcyon time. If we did though this forum wouldn't exist and [glow=red,2,300]most of the members on it would probably have the 21st century equivalent of athena posters on their wall[/glow]. um, drums fingers looking around flat. pictures on walls is the athena of the 21st century!!! i liked the show however I think similar distain has always been apparent throughout time with new artistic movements. very few new art movements have been embraced by their contemporary audience, and if they had the means to replicate images back in the high rennaissance I am sure they would have done. technology is one of the main driving forces in art as it is in most sectors. and with new technology comes new forms of art. i think he wouldrather we all had blank walls, and only had museum walls to admire!!! looking forward to parts 2 and 3 though!!!!
|
|
pezlow
Junior Member
Posts โข 5,388
Likes โข 254
January 2007
|
Must watch TV - The Mona Lisa Curse C4 6.30pm, by pezlow on Sept 22, 2008 8:44:07 GMT 1, Except that this time around new artistic movements are being embraced...people flock to see the latest contemporary art on display in museums, galleries and, yes, auction houses.
I agree with your point about technology as well.
Except that this time around new artistic movements are being embraced...people flock to see the latest contemporary art on display in museums, galleries and, yes, auction houses.
I agree with your point about technology as well.
|
|
bmjt
New Member
Posts โข 908
Likes โข 7
April 2008
|
Must watch TV - The Mona Lisa Curse C4 6.30pm, by bmjt on Sept 22, 2008 9:03:05 GMT 1, Hughes eloquence & intelligence on the subject was perfectly juxtapositioned with Mugrabe,s ignorant observations,scary that morons like these can manipulate the market so easily. Great programme,good to see that Hirst didnt escape his vitriol too.
My sentiments entirely.
Hughes eloquence & intelligence on the subject was perfectly juxtapositioned with Mugrabe,s ignorant observations,scary that morons like these can manipulate the market so easily. Great programme,good to see that Hirst didnt escape his vitriol too. My sentiments entirely.
|
|
|
Must watch TV - The Mona Lisa Curse C4 6.30pm, by Guest on Sept 22, 2008 9:12:49 GMT 1, I thought it was a great show, one of the best i have seen on the art market in general. A lot of what Hughes said made sense, we see quiet a lot of that at our end of the market, with flippers only buying art for profit, not for the art at all, so i imagine the same is true for the big bucks paintings, and the manipulation of prices by collectors to inflate their own collection. with galleries and museums being priced out of the market completely.
If you missed the show, its well worth a look.
I thought it was a great show, one of the best i have seen on the art market in general. A lot of what Hughes said made sense, we see quiet a lot of that at our end of the market, with flippers only buying art for profit, not for the art at all, so i imagine the same is true for the big bucks paintings, and the manipulation of prices by collectors to inflate their own collection. with galleries and museums being priced out of the market completely.
If you missed the show, its well worth a look.
|
|
|
Must watch TV - The Mona Lisa Curse C4 6.30pm, by havana07 on Sept 22, 2008 11:23:41 GMT 1, Hughes eloquence & intelligence on the subject was perfectly juxtapositioned with Mugrabe,s ignorant observations,scary that morons like these can manipulate the market so easily. Great programme,good to see that Hirst didnt escape his vitriol too.
Hughes is a moron and a tosspot. Most of the art we buy are derived in some way from Grandpa Warhol and Papa Hirst. All throughout Basquiats short life, Hughes thought his art was a joke and I have news for all us art collectors, Hughes thinks all the art we buy is shit as well!
As for Mugrabe, anyone who can go round the backrooms of America and clean old dealers out of Warhols for next to nothing had great verve, single mindedness, and brass balls. That interview was staged. Mugrabes real feelings on that old barracuda couldn't even be repeated on TV.
If he had it his way, we would have to slavishly follow his sermon that Museums should be mausoleums stuffed with prehistoric art that only the 'privileged' should pontificate about and the rest of us shouldn't be able to understand.
Other than that, he wasn't even a real hippy in the 60's!
Hughes eloquence & intelligence on the subject was perfectly juxtapositioned with Mugrabe,s ignorant observations,scary that morons like these can manipulate the market so easily. Great programme,good to see that Hirst didnt escape his vitriol too. Hughes is a moron and a tosspot. Most of the art we buy are derived in some way from Grandpa Warhol and Papa Hirst. All throughout Basquiats short life, Hughes thought his art was a joke and I have news for all us art collectors, Hughes thinks all the art we buy is shit as well! As for Mugrabe, anyone who can go round the backrooms of America and clean old dealers out of Warhols for next to nothing had great verve, single mindedness, and brass balls. That interview was staged. Mugrabes real feelings on that old barracuda couldn't even be repeated on TV. If he had it his way, we would have to slavishly follow his sermon that Museums should be mausoleums stuffed with prehistoric art that only the 'privileged' should pontificate about and the rest of us shouldn't be able to understand. Other than that, he wasn't even a real hippy in the 60's!
|
|
barry cilit
New Member
Posts โข 298
Likes โข 0
March 2007
|
Must watch TV - The Mona Lisa Curse C4 6.30pm, by barry cilit on Sept 22, 2008 11:54:46 GMT 1, Finally!! someone else who thinks Hirst and Warhol are talentless pieces of crap!! excellent watch!
Finally!! someone else who thinks Hirst and Warhol are talentless pieces of crap!! excellent watch!
|
|
|
|
bmjt
New Member
Posts โข 908
Likes โข 7
April 2008
|
Must watch TV - The Mona Lisa Curse C4 6.30pm, by bmjt on Sept 22, 2008 13:13:02 GMT 1, Really interesting, cheers for the link. Without wanting to read too much into it; given it spans their ast history in a matter of a few hundred words, it does seem that his only impulse to buy is to sell on at a huge profit without any real interest in the art, with no mention of why he liked it bar the financial gains.* Which, in my opinion, simply makes him a huge-scale flipper, doing his best to force up the price of his collection. No love, except for money, unlike Hughes. Murgrabe is the 'tosspot'.
(*Bar the comment about Warhol as the Authentic American; a instantly recognizable influence, but then again, wouldn't that be a key reason for investing in the first place? Knowing that his money is safe and prices will rise, which he machinates anyway)
Really interesting, cheers for the link. Without wanting to read too much into it; given it spans their ast history in a matter of a few hundred words, it does seem that his only impulse to buy is to sell on at a huge profit without any real interest in the art, with no mention of why he liked it bar the financial gains.* Which, in my opinion, simply makes him a huge-scale flipper, doing his best to force up the price of his collection. No love, except for money, unlike Hughes. Murgrabe is the 'tosspot'.
(*Bar the comment about Warhol as the Authentic American; a instantly recognizable influence, but then again, wouldn't that be a key reason for investing in the first place? Knowing that his money is safe and prices will rise, which he machinates anyway)
|
|
Va Va Voom
New Member
Posts โข 631
Likes โข 135
October 2006
|
Must watch TV - The Mona Lisa Curse C4 6.30pm, by Va Va Voom on Sept 22, 2008 23:09:23 GMT 1, Hughes eloquence & intelligence on the subject was perfectly juxtapositioned with Mugrabe,s ignorant observations,scary that morons like these can manipulate the market so easily. Great programme,good to see that Hirst didnt escape his vitriol too. Hughes is a moron and a tosspot. Most of the art we buy are derived in some way from Grandpa Warhol and Papa Hirst. All throughout Basquiats short life, Hughes thought his art was a joke and I have news for all us art collectors, Hughes thinks all the art we buy is s**t as well! As for Mugrabe, anyone who can go round the backrooms of America and clean old dealers out of Warhols for next to nothing had great verve, single mindedness, and brass balls. That interview was staged. Mugrabes real feelings on that old barracuda couldn't even be repeated on TV. If he had it his way, we would have to slavishly follow his sermon that Museums should be mausoleums stuffed with prehistoric art that only the 'privileged' should pontificate about and the rest of us shouldn't be able to understand. Other than that, he wasn't even a real hippy in the 60's!
"Moron & Tosspot"...Havana I am surprised at you with this comment,one thing he is not is a moron.I certainly do not agree with all of his opinions( my love for Basquiats work you know only too well), but lots of the work from this scene is crap..fact !! Mugrabes real feelings I would love to hear because when he was given the opportunity to express the qualities of the artists his father collects,he was embarrassingly monosyllabic...in fact he had no true feelings for the work outside of the value. As for great verve and brass balls....lets you and me tour around with a sponsors money buying up Warhols,no sweat and we would have a party...so no admiration for that. "Museums should be mausoleums"..dont agree with this either, I felt that a reasonably balanced opinion was expressed via the Guggenheim and the (very entertaining) ex director of the Metropolitan Museum of Art on the merits of popularizing the previously stuffy museums into people friendly environments.
Hughes eloquence & intelligence on the subject was perfectly juxtapositioned with Mugrabe,s ignorant observations,scary that morons like these can manipulate the market so easily. Great programme,good to see that Hirst didnt escape his vitriol too. Hughes is a moron and a tosspot. Most of the art we buy are derived in some way from Grandpa Warhol and Papa Hirst. All throughout Basquiats short life, Hughes thought his art was a joke and I have news for all us art collectors, Hughes thinks all the art we buy is s**t as well! As for Mugrabe, anyone who can go round the backrooms of America and clean old dealers out of Warhols for next to nothing had great verve, single mindedness, and brass balls. That interview was staged. Mugrabes real feelings on that old barracuda couldn't even be repeated on TV. If he had it his way, we would have to slavishly follow his sermon that Museums should be mausoleums stuffed with prehistoric art that only the 'privileged' should pontificate about and the rest of us shouldn't be able to understand. Other than that, he wasn't even a real hippy in the 60's! "Moron & Tosspot"...Havana I am surprised at you with this comment,one thing he is not is a moron.I certainly do not agree with all of his opinions( my love for Basquiats work you know only too well), but lots of the work from this scene is crap..fact !! Mugrabes real feelings I would love to hear because when he was given the opportunity to express the qualities of the artists his father collects,he was embarrassingly monosyllabic...in fact he had no true feelings for the work outside of the value. As for great verve and brass balls....lets you and me tour around with a sponsors money buying up Warhols,no sweat and we would have a party...so no admiration for that. "Museums should be mausoleums"..dont agree with this either, I felt that a reasonably balanced opinion was expressed via the Guggenheim and the (very entertaining) ex director of the Metropolitan Museum of Art on the merits of popularizing the previously stuffy museums into people friendly environments.
|
|
Bram
Artist
Junior Member
Posts โข 2,818
Likes โข 295
November 2007
|
Must watch TV - The Mona Lisa Curse C4 6.30pm, by Bram on Sept 23, 2008 17:39:36 GMT 1, If you noticed the Art Radio station from Manhattan that was playing in the background, the link is here www.wps1.org/new_site/index.php
|
|
Va Va Voom
New Member
Posts โข 631
Likes โข 135
October 2006
|
Must watch TV - The Mona Lisa Curse C4 6.30pm, by Va Va Voom on Sept 24, 2008 20:06:06 GMT 1,
Thanks for that Bram.
|
|