|
|
Artist stars, by Daniel Silk on Jan 21, 2012 18:20:47 GMT 1, It's reflecting your opinions! You all had the chance to nominate and vote over two years of awards, it cant get any more fair than that.
All it will do is show the combined and simplified results from the Awards.
If you didn't vote, or you don't like Awards, then that's fine  but allow those that did vote see the results.
It's reflecting your opinions! You all had the chance to nominate and vote over two years of awards, it cant get any more fair than that. All it will do is show the combined and simplified results from the Awards. If you didn't vote, or you don't like Awards, then that's fine but allow those that did vote see the results. |
|
|
|
Artist stars, by Daniel Silk on Jan 21, 2012 18:27:18 GMT 1, Don't get hung up on the stars now, they are all going to be removed!
It's just going to show the results of the awards.
Don't get hung up on the stars now, they are all going to be removed!
It's just going to show the results of the awards.
|
|
johnnyh
Junior Member
🗨️ 4,492
👍🏻 2,102
March 2011
|
Artist stars, by johnnyh on Jan 21, 2012 18:47:16 GMT 1, Thx Daniel no one is complaing about the awards or the results.
I did not vote as do not see enough street or galleries etc.
So have no worries about the results as they do reflect the opinions of those
Who voted and no one winners losers, members etc can complain about that they are what they are.
Know you put a lot of effort more than us into the forum and massive respect for that not always shown but members
Do appreciate that.
Thx from a lot of us for re considering and not making star based
Johnny
Thx Daniel no one is complaing about the awards or the results.
I did not vote as do not see enough street or galleries etc.
So have no worries about the results as they do reflect the opinions of those
Who voted and no one winners losers, members etc can complain about that they are what they are.
Know you put a lot of effort more than us into the forum and massive respect for that not always shown but members
Do appreciate that.
Thx from a lot of us for re considering and not making star based
Johnny
|
|
|
|
Artist stars, by Daniel Silk on Jan 21, 2012 18:57:56 GMT 1, Thanks very much
I'm still trying to work it all out, but you can see the results so far here - urbanartassociation.com/index.cgi?board=urbanart&action=display&thread=91100
I say again, it's just a work in progress as I try to find a nice simplified way to show the results of the Awards.
BTW please let me know if I have added anything up wrong 
|
|
johnnyh
Junior Member
🗨️ 4,492
👍🏻 2,102
March 2011
|
Artist stars, by johnnyh on Jan 21, 2012 19:07:56 GMT 1, Daniel - you honestly do not want my maths involved.
I do not spend much on art!!! However if you need help with the maths
Will give you my wife's email she tells me exactly how much I have spent!!!
Much appreciated
Cheers
Johnny
Daniel - you honestly do not want my maths involved.
I do not spend much on art!!! However if you need help with the maths
Will give you my wife's email she tells me exactly how much I have spent!!!
Much appreciated
Cheers
Johnny
|
|
|
|
Artist stars, by maumau93 on Jan 21, 2012 21:12:46 GMT 1, Don't get hung up on the stars now, they are all going to be removed! It's just going to show the results of the awards.
cool! thanks for that! it was nothing personal and i do realise it takes time to run a site but it was just something that had bugged me (and obviously many others) since joining this place...
cheers,
five
Don't get hung up on the stars now, they are all going to be removed! It's just going to show the results of the awards. cool! thanks for that! it was nothing personal and i do realise it takes time to run a site but it was just something that had bugged me (and obviously many others) since joining this place... cheers, five |
|
|
|
|
|
Artist stars, by Daniel Silk on Jan 21, 2012 21:37:04 GMT 1, Don't get hung up on the stars now, they are all going to be removed! It's just going to show the results of the awards. cool! thanks for that! it was nothing personal and i do realise it takes time to run a site but it was just something that had bugged me (and obviously many others) since joining this place... cheers, five
No probs, it was always the plan to change to them being set by the awards results in the end anyway. Now we have two years of results to go on it gives much clearer and more accurate figure to work by.
I will try to get it all changed over this next week.
Don't get hung up on the stars now, they are all going to be removed! It's just going to show the results of the awards. cool! thanks for that! it was nothing personal and i do realise it takes time to run a site but it was just something that had bugged me (and obviously many others) since joining this place... cheers, five No probs, it was always the plan to change to them being set by the awards results in the end anyway. Now we have two years of results to go on it gives much clearer and more accurate figure to work by. I will try to get it all changed over this next week. |
|
|
|
johnnyh
Junior Member
🗨️ 4,492
👍🏻 2,102
March 2011
|
Artist stars, by johnnyh on Jan 22, 2012 11:37:22 GMT 1, Daniel really surprised that you are still pursuing this.
Have you considered that actually very few people vote. Eg there are only 6 artists who have got over 100 votes in two years in almost every continent. Think your star system is based upon the fact that no one votes. So with such low demographics how can you say this is accurate or reflective of people's thoughts.
Let alone the fact have you contacted any artists to gauge their feeling on being star rated.
The members of this board in all I have read do not support this concept so I would assume the artists do not either.
Good luck sure you will have set the new mitchellin star rating for artists. Graffiti moves from the street to the kitchen.
Saturday morning spray - with your host Daniel and **** guest artist DFace showing how to spray your garden wall
Mmmmmmmm
Daniel really surprised that you are still pursuing this.
Have you considered that actually very few people vote. Eg there are only 6 artists who have got over 100 votes in two years in almost every continent. Think your star system is based upon the fact that no one votes. So with such low demographics how can you say this is accurate or reflective of people's thoughts.
Let alone the fact have you contacted any artists to gauge their feeling on being star rated.
The members of this board in all I have read do not support this concept so I would assume the artists do not either.
Good luck sure you will have set the new mitchellin star rating for artists. Graffiti moves from the street to the kitchen.
Saturday morning spray - with your host Daniel and **** guest artist DFace showing how to spray your garden wall
Mmmmmmmm
|
|
|
|
Artist stars, by maumau93 on Jan 22, 2012 11:47:47 GMT 1,  not to sure whats goin on now i thought you where getting rid of the stars?
not to sure whats goin on now i thought you where getting rid of the stars? |
|
|
|
Artist stars, by Daniel Silk on Jan 22, 2012 11:55:48 GMT 1, You all come here to look at Artists work and to post your opinions, we have a yearly vote so you can all vote with your opinions, and all its doing is displaying the results.
You all come here to look at Artists work and to post your opinions, we have a yearly vote so you can all vote with your opinions, and all its doing is displaying the results.
|
|
|
|
Artist stars, by Daniel Silk on Jan 22, 2012 11:56:44 GMT 1, not to sure whats goin on now i thought you where getting rid of the stars?
I dont understand what going on as well  Why do you have a problem with stars?
not to sure whats goin on now i thought you where getting rid of the stars? I dont understand what going on as well Why do you have a problem with stars? |
|
|
|
Artist stars, by boatyyy on Jan 22, 2012 12:04:39 GMT 1, lollllll
this rating topic is like SOPA - just when you think it's dead you realized it was just shelved for a minute....
lollll - you guys are a funny bunch....
lollllll
this rating topic is like SOPA - just when you think it's dead you realized it was just shelved for a minute....
lollll - you guys are a funny bunch....
|
|
|
|
Artist stars, by Daniel Silk on Jan 22, 2012 12:06:47 GMT 1, Im having trouble understanding what your trying to tell me
Coz it sounds like you dont want the results of the Awards to be shown incase it upsets Artists who didnt get many votes?
But the forum is all about people posting their opinions about Artists work, so I really dont understand sorry.
Im having trouble understanding what your trying to tell me Coz it sounds like you dont want the results of the Awards to be shown incase it upsets Artists who didnt get many votes? But the forum is all about people posting their opinions about Artists work, so I really dont understand sorry. |
|
|
|
johnnyh
Junior Member
🗨️ 4,492
👍🏻 2,102
March 2011
|
Artist stars, by johnnyh on Jan 22, 2012 12:10:05 GMT 1, Daniel your stars and the usage of stars implies the value credibility of an artist otherwise why would you do it.
It is not a defacto rule that you have to vote in your slightly daft awards. That's shown by the number of votes v the number of members.
Can you explain why you want to rate artists. Can you explain any artists who have said that they would welcome being star rated
Daniel your stars and the usage of stars implies the value credibility of an artist otherwise why would you do it.
It is not a defacto rule that you have to vote in your slightly daft awards. That's shown by the number of votes v the number of members.
Can you explain why you want to rate artists. Can you explain any artists who have said that they would welcome being star rated
|
|
|
|
Artist stars, by Daniel Silk on Jan 22, 2012 12:17:07 GMT 1, Daniel your stars and the usage of stars implies the value credibility of an artist otherwise why would you do it. It is not a defacto rule that you have to vote in your slightly daft awards. That's shown by the number of votes v the number of members. Can you explain why you want to rate artists. Can you explain any artists who have said that they would welcome being star rated
I dont understand your reasoning sorry
The number of stars is set by forum members votes!
If you didnt vote or you just dont like the awards, that doesnt mean everyone has to be ruled by your opinion Your all given the choice.
I dont think some of you have yet taken onboard that its the results of the Awards!
Daniel your stars and the usage of stars implies the value credibility of an artist otherwise why would you do it. It is not a defacto rule that you have to vote in your slightly daft awards. That's shown by the number of votes v the number of members. Can you explain why you want to rate artists. Can you explain any artists who have said that they would welcome being star rated I dont understand your reasoning sorry The number of stars is set by forum members votes! If you didnt vote or you just dont like the awards, that doesnt mean everyone has to be ruled by your opinion Your all given the choice. I dont think some of you have yet taken onboard that its the results of the Awards! |
|
|
|
Artist stars, by boatyyy on Jan 22, 2012 12:17:17 GMT 1, ok, silky - this forum is a phenom - to me anyway; so i trust your vision...
but, putting aside concepts etc... practically speaking there is simply not enough data to support this idea or the ratings at the mo; consider giving it some more time and data mining...
ok, silky - this forum is a phenom - to me anyway; so i trust your vision...
but, putting aside concepts etc... practically speaking there is simply not enough data to support this idea or the ratings at the mo; consider giving it some more time and data mining...
|
|
|
|
Artist stars, by Daniel Silk on Jan 22, 2012 12:21:42 GMT 1, ok, silky - this forum is a phenom - to me anyway; so i trust your vision... but, putting aside concepts etc... practically speaking there is simply not enough data to support this idea or the ratings at the mo; consider giving it some more time and data mining...
Yes, I think the results from the first years awards didn't really give enough data to give a fair representation, but with now two years combined I think the results look pretty good.
Of course it will get better each year 
ok, silky - this forum is a phenom - to me anyway; so i trust your vision... but, putting aside concepts etc... practically speaking there is simply not enough data to support this idea or the ratings at the mo; consider giving it some more time and data mining... Yes, I think the results from the first years awards didn't really give enough data to give a fair representation, but with now two years combined I think the results look pretty good. Of course it will get better each year |
|
johnnyh
Junior Member
🗨️ 4,492
👍🏻 2,102
March 2011
|
Artist stars, by johnnyh on Jan 22, 2012 12:25:24 GMT 1, Daniel
Not complaining about the results or you running your awards. Print the number of votes that's fine. That shows how people voted and how many voted. However your star system implies some one is not necessarily a good artist IMO based upon a very small sample. If you cannot see that then not sure what else there is to say on it.
But IMO and I think a lot of other people's it is wrong. End of story.
Please talk to people who have been here a long time do not listen to me I am not as qualified as the long term members so talk to them privately and see what they say.
That's all I would ask your forum not ours.
Daniel
Not complaining about the results or you running your awards. Print the number of votes that's fine. That shows how people voted and how many voted. However your star system implies some one is not necessarily a good artist IMO based upon a very small sample. If you cannot see that then not sure what else there is to say on it.
But IMO and I think a lot of other people's it is wrong. End of story.
Please talk to people who have been here a long time do not listen to me I am not as qualified as the long term members so talk to them privately and see what they say.
That's all I would ask your forum not ours.
|
|
parp
New Member
🗨️ 65
👍🏻 1
April 2011
|
Artist stars, by parp on Jan 22, 2012 12:33:48 GMT 1, Lots of people getting worked up about the colour of peoples stars on an internet forum #realitycheck
Lots of people getting worked up about the colour of peoples stars on an internet forum #realitycheck
|
|
|
|
Artist stars, by boatyyy on Jan 22, 2012 12:34:25 GMT 1, ok, ok... for fun, let's try level setting for a min... consider an analogy...
how long did it take al pacino and robert de niro to get oscars? long long time... and look at the products they produced - unmatched... now if you correlated those awards to their skills and products it woud never make sense, no?...
ok, ok... for fun, let's try level setting for a min... consider an analogy...
how long did it take al pacino and robert de niro to get oscars? long long time... and look at the products they produced - unmatched... now if you correlated those awards to their skills and products it woud never make sense, no?...
|
|
|
|
Artist stars, by Daniel Silk on Jan 22, 2012 12:35:04 GMT 1, The whole forum is about posting your opinions about Artists work. Some Artists are much more popular than other Artists, everyone knows that, and pretty much every thread on the forum reflects it.
The Awards is voted by members of the forum and is just another show of their opinions, just the same as you personally going onto a thread and rating an Artists work with your comments.
The whole forum is about posting your opinions about Artists work. Some Artists are much more popular than other Artists, everyone knows that, and pretty much every thread on the forum reflects it.
The Awards is voted by members of the forum and is just another show of their opinions, just the same as you personally going onto a thread and rating an Artists work with your comments.
|
|
|
|
|
|
Artist stars, by maumau93 on Jan 22, 2012 12:46:04 GMT 1, why do they need to say who's popular?
ok how about just keeping the one star in red then like on yours it says administrator you could have the name of the award and the year they won it?
then there is no need to rate an artist on popularity?
why do they need to say who's popular?
ok how about just keeping the one star in red then like on yours it says administrator you could have the name of the award and the year they won it?
then there is no need to rate an artist on popularity?
|
|
|
|
Artist stars, by Daniel Silk on Jan 22, 2012 12:52:03 GMT 1, why do they need to say who's popular? ok how about just keeping the one star in red then like on yours it says administrator you could have the name of the award and the year they won it? then there is no need to rate an artist on popularity?
I think you have got confused we are not talking about those coloured stars.
why do they need to say who's popular? ok how about just keeping the one star in red then like on yours it says administrator you could have the name of the award and the year they won it? then there is no need to rate an artist on popularity? I think you have got confused we are not talking about those coloured stars. |
|
|
|
Artist stars, by freeview on Jan 22, 2012 13:48:18 GMT 1, Just spotted I have My Jago down on the list two times  a mistake somewhere
lol
Just spotted I have My Jago down on the list two times a mistake somewhere lol |
|
|
|
Artist stars, by Daniel Silk on Jan 22, 2012 13:57:39 GMT 1, Just spotted I have My Jago down on the list two times a mistake somewhere lol
Sorted it out and he's gone up the list a bit.
Just spotted I have My Jago down on the list two times a mistake somewhere lol Sorted it out and he's gone up the list a bit. |
|
but allow those that did vote see the results.
not to sure whats goin on now i thought you where getting rid of the stars?
Why do you have a problem with stars?
a mistake somewhere
